The Japan Times - China censors zero-Covid debate after WHO criticises policy

EUR -
AED 4.18418
AFN 72.345505
ALL 94.14615
AMD 419.060304
ANG 2.039857
AOA 1044.764284
ARS 1665.100202
AUD 1.642689
AWG 2.050791
AZN 1.941648
BAM 1.954682
BBD 2.294887
BDT 139.979934
BGN 1.926468
BHD 0.429754
BIF 3403.453278
BMD 1.139328
BND 1.476056
BOB 7.890487
BRL 5.896304
BSD 1.139448
BTN 107.880294
BWP 15.494138
BYN 3.20017
BYR 22330.835112
BZD 2.291569
CAD 1.616491
CDF 2580.578112
CHF 0.922517
CLF 0.026329
CLP 1036.378473
CNY 7.718721
CNH 7.735219
COP 3924.530338
CRC 516.904339
CUC 1.139328
CUP 30.192201
CVE 110.201966
CZK 24.20606
DJF 202.903942
DKK 7.474911
DOP 66.691853
DZD 152.212235
EGP 56.643191
ERN 17.089925
ETB 183.698927
FJD 2.555342
FKP 0.860054
GBP 0.861976
GEL 3.013567
GGP 0.860054
GHS 12.789685
GIP 0.860054
GMD 83.170728
GNF 9984.289143
GTQ 8.692913
GYD 238.383648
HKD 8.932322
HNL 30.485162
HRK 7.537682
HTG 148.974789
HUF 354.579516
IDR 20418.073759
ILS 3.414794
IMP 0.860054
INR 107.95096
IQD 1492.64623
IRR 1566576.442968
ISK 143.87478
JEP 0.860054
JMD 179.35741
JOD 0.807752
JPY 184.064757
KES 147.485994
KGS 99.63461
KHR 4573.384096
KMF 491.050622
KPW 1025.395889
KRW 1750.412809
KWD 0.352075
KYD 0.949557
KZT 554.252976
LAK 25232.346027
LBP 102035.337387
LKR 381.221947
LRD 207.371387
LSL 18.789205
LTL 3.36414
LVL 0.689168
LYD 7.311818
MAD 10.6644
MDL 20.059526
MGA 4760.235439
MKD 61.67035
MMK 2391.891494
MNT 4077.656082
MOP 9.201637
MRU 45.257518
MUR 54.642279
MVR 17.613896
MWK 1975.769891
MXN 19.922466
MYR 4.717392
MZN 72.805701
NAD 18.789205
NGN 1559.063043
NIO 41.926019
NOK 11.144911
NPR 172.608271
NZD 2.006944
OMR 0.438074
PAB 1.139448
PEN 3.856994
PGK 4.997142
PHP 69.77645
PKR 316.902137
PLN 4.282564
PYG 6945.935586
QAR 4.153588
RON 5.248198
RSD 117.394087
RUB 84.936921
RWF 1670.944246
SAR 4.27737
SBD 9.188729
SCR 16.014934
SDG 684.167236
SEK 11.061015
SGD 1.476393
SHP 0.850624
SLE 28.198016
SLL 23891.149424
SOS 651.227508
SRD 42.645626
STD 23581.795972
STN 24.485994
SVC 9.970297
SYP 125.932349
SZL 18.783256
THB 37.82285
TJS 10.568155
TMT 3.999042
TND 3.372771
TOP 2.74323
TRY 52.955177
TTD 7.736575
TWD 36.070561
TZS 2991.0012
UAH 51.147544
UGX 4170.614474
USD 1.139328
UYU 45.703257
UZS 13689.989303
VES 702.812079
VND 29992.818078
VUV 135.304952
WST 3.140359
XAF 655.582017
XAG 0.018352
XAU 0.000276
XCD 3.079092
XCG 2.053525
XDR 0.813361
XOF 655.582017
XPF 119.331742
YER 271.900837
ZAR 18.785302
ZMK 10255.314604
ZMW 20.440308
ZWL 366.863255
  • CMSC

    -0.2100

    22.16

    -0.95%

  • BCC

    -2.1200

    72.54

    -2.92%

  • BP

    0.6800

    39.78

    +1.71%

  • GSK

    0.0700

    50.74

    +0.14%

  • CMSD

    -0.2100

    22.08

    -0.95%

  • RBGPF

    -0.2700

    60.34

    -0.45%

  • RIO

    -0.7200

    99.36

    -0.72%

  • NGG

    1.5300

    80.97

    +1.89%

  • BCE

    -0.6300

    22.65

    -2.78%

  • BTI

    -0.0100

    58.9

    -0.02%

  • RYCEF

    0.2300

    18.63

    +1.23%

  • JRI

    -0.0200

    12.65

    -0.16%

  • VOD

    -0.1800

    14.12

    -1.27%

  • RELX

    -0.3500

    30.83

    -1.14%

  • AZN

    1.5000

    176.43

    +0.85%

China censors zero-Covid debate after WHO criticises policy
China censors zero-Covid debate after WHO criticises policy / Photo: Noel Celis - AFP

China censors zero-Covid debate after WHO criticises policy

China's censors scrambled to wipe out online debate over its zero-Covid strategy on Wednesday after the World Health Organisation (WHO) criticised the country's hardline approach to crushing the virus.

Text size:

China is the last major economy glued to a zero-Covid policy and enforces some of the most stringent virus controls anywhere in the world.

Those restrictions have trapped most of Shanghai's 25 million people in a lockdown with no clear end date, while Beijing has also gradually corralled many of its residents indoors as it battles its biggest outbreak since the pandemic began.

On Tuesday WHO chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus urged China to change tack, saying the approach "will not be sustainable" in the face of new fast-spreading variants.

The intervention prompted China's army of internet censors to race to snuff out his comments.

Searches for the hashtags "Tedros" and "who" on the popular Weibo social media platform displayed no results, while users of the WeChat app were unable to share an article posted on an official United Nations account.

A social media hashtag about the WHO's comments, which had been a rallying point for lively online discussion, appeared to have been blocked by mid-morning.

Before they were expunged from the internet, comments had questioned zero-Covid, with one saying "even the WHO's Tedros has now changed his stance".

Another wrote: "Will our government listen to the WHO director general's recommendations?"

Virus controls are causing mounting anger and frustration, especially in Shanghai where residents have raged against seemingly endless lockdowns, spartan quarantine facilities and heavy-handed enforcement.

The city has witnessed repeated protests and violent scuffles with police, rare images which have pinballed across social media before censors can catch up.

The ruling Communist Party says its virus strategy places life before material concerns and has averted the public health crises seen in other nations.

A foreign ministry spokesman brushed off questions about the WHO's comments on Wednesday, saying Beijing's policy "can stand the test of history" and was "scientific and effective."

"We hope that relevant individuals can take an objective and rational view of China's epidemic prevention and control policies ... and refrain from making irresponsible remarks," Zhao Lijian said at a regular press conference.

Abandoning zero-Covid and allowing Omicron to rip across the country could result in 1.6 million deaths, according to a paper published Tuesday in the peer-reviewed journal Nature by researchers at Shanghai's Fudan University.

Health officials have said vaccination rates are low among the elderly and warn rural health facilities risk collapse under an Omicron surge.

On Monday, vice-premier Sun Chunlan reminded disease control officials of the political imperatives attached to zero-Covid.

It is necessary to "create the conditions for the victorious convening of the 20th Party Congress", she said, according to state news agency Xinhua.

The twice-a-decade conclave scheduled for later this year is expected to see President Xi Jinping secure an unprecedented third consecutive term as the leader of the world's number two economy.

Discussing Beijing's zero-Covid strategy on Tuesday, Tedros said WHO experts "don't think that it's sustainable, considering the behaviour of the virus now and what we anticipate in the future".

Hu Xijin, the influential former editor of Chinese state tabloid Global Times, slammed the comments in a message to his 24 million Weibo followers, saying "in the end, the WHO's attitude isn't important".

M.Yamazaki--JT