The Japan Times - UK's aristocratic lawmakers prepare for life after the Lords

EUR -
AED 4.09717
AFN 71.955477
ALL 90.307485
AMD 402.108707
ANG 1.996748
AOA 1024.153221
ARS 1724.405821
AUD 1.627572
AWG 2.010933
AZN 1.894218
BAM 1.945165
BBD 2.247115
BDT 139.102616
BGN 1.949942
BHD 0.420904
BIF 3337.627328
BMD 1.115636
BND 1.426334
BOB 13.231837
BRL 6.237963
BSD 1.115725
BTN 104.853157
BWP 15.306522
BYN 3.340611
BYR 21866.457781
BZD 2.243883
CAD 1.582881
CDF 2555.921248
CHF 0.921509
CLF 0.027952
CLP 1100.106009
CNY 7.444416
CNH 7.450103
COP 3678.696831
CRC 504.652276
CUC 1.115636
CUP 26.776607
CVE 109.666415
CZK 24.363641
DJF 198.270461
DKK 7.475757
DOP 67.670638
DZD 152.368275
EGP 59.432696
ERN 16.734534
ETB 181.592241
FJD 2.520723
FKP 0.831321
GBP 0.836743
GEL 2.889263
GGP 0.831321
GHS 13.064748
GIP 0.831321
GMD 82.557231
GNF 9884.182724
GTQ 8.525466
GYD 233.781869
HKD 8.752596
HNL 29.990039
HRK 7.551749
HTG 146.243734
HUF 364.783839
IDR 20225.525157
ILS 3.551012
IMP 0.831321
INR 104.581244
IQD 1691.368119
IRR 2122257.426818
ISK 136.821862
JEP 0.831321
JMD 177.07586
JOD 0.790991
JPY 177.189705
KES 144.966119
KGS 97.562111
KHR 4550.184426
KMF 489.764092
KPW 1004.071998
KRW 1499.547584
KWD 0.347097
KYD 0.929729
KZT 498.113413
LAK 25113.039731
LBP 99909.276364
LKR 370.791121
LRD 189.657157
LSL 18.290864
LTL 3.294182
LVL 0.674837
LYD 7.151963
MAD 10.88349
MDL 20.04866
MGA 5062.390979
MKD 61.570696
MMK 2342.496191
MNT 4017.905911
MOP 9.014455
MRU 45.007339
MUR 52.345629
MVR 17.192133
MWK 1934.648906
MXN 20.826083
MYR 4.525461
MZN 71.300204
NAD 18.290701
NGN 1504.044211
NIO 41.056456
NOK 10.618893
NPR 167.766547
NZD 1.994478
OMR 0.428996
PAB 1.115715
PEN 3.802397
PGK 5.01074
PHP 70.468041
PKR 308.565808
PLN 4.397507
PYG 6887.49903
QAR 4.067001
RON 5.345116
RSD 117.602474
RUB 92.795072
RWF 1650.697507
SAR 4.195254
SBD 9.033635
SCR 15.544939
SDG 671.051455
SEK 11.036838
SGD 1.430747
SHP 0.830117
SLE 25.60372
SLL 23394.325643
SOS 637.619723
SRD 41.887623
STD 23091.404483
STN 24.367325
SVC 9.762843
SYP 14505.493733
SZL 18.296135
THB 37.529772
TJS 10.252961
TMT 3.915881
TND 3.325121
TOP 2.686182
TRY 56.041735
TTD 7.5668
TWD 36.811069
TZS 2948.825547
UAH 50.746126
UGX 4552.112706
USD 1.115636
UYU 45.143596
UZS 13360.077585
VES 1000.926228
VND 28560.271387
VUV 133.877508
WST 3.101582
XAF 655.957
XAG 0.021768
XAU 0.000277651486
XCD 3.015061
XCG 2.010734
XDR 0.788812
XOF 655.957
XPF 119.331742
YER 263.84649
ZAR 18.479902
ZMK 10042.130126
ZMW 22.731721
ZWL 359.234208
SSP 6410.235276
MXV 2.340622
  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    19.81

    +0.5%

  • VOD

    -0.2500

    16.33

    -1.53%

  • CMSC

    -0.2800

    20.12

    -1.39%

  • RBGPF

    -2.0000

    65

    -3.08%

  • RIO

    -0.2500

    94.16

    -0.27%

  • BTI

    -1.2000

    54.85

    -2.19%

  • NGG

    -0.3000

    74.94

    -0.4%

  • GSK

    -0.3500

    49.35

    -0.71%

  • BCE

    -0.4200

    20.14

    -2.09%

  • CMSD

    -0.3400

    19.93

    -1.71%

  • BP

    -0.9100

    43.52

    -2.09%

  • RELX

    0.1700

    33.24

    +0.51%

  • BCC

    -0.6200

    75.97

    -0.82%

  • AZN

    -1.9400

    164.21

    -1.18%

  • JRI

    0.0000

    10.77

    0%

UK's aristocratic lawmakers prepare for life after the Lords
UK's aristocratic lawmakers prepare for life after the Lords / Photo: Paul ELLIS - AFP

UK's aristocratic lawmakers prepare for life after the Lords

UK hereditary lawmaker Richard Fletcher-Vane, better known as Lord Inglewood, will soon no longer commute the few hundred miles from his country house in northwest England to the House of Lords in London -- and he is not happy about it.

Text size:

"Anybody who's sacked doesn't like it, particularly if you think you're being sacked for what per se is a bad reason," he told AFP at Hutton-in-the-Forest, his vast home dating back to 1350 near Penrith, Cumbria, 300 miles (480 kilometres) from Britain's capital.

The Labour government elected earlier this year is axing the 92 seats reserved for peers who inherited their position as a member of an aristocratic family, as the centre-left party moves to reform parliament's unelected upper chamber.

Britain is an anomaly among Western governments in having such lawmakers, who hold titles such as duke, earl, viscount and baron.

Lesotho in southern Africa is the only other country in the world with a hereditary element in its legislature, according to the UK government.

It is "out of step with modern Britain," government minister Nick Thomas-Symonds said in September as he introduced the legislation that will scrap the Lords' bloodline members.

The proposals were quickly approved by the House of Commons lower chamber and will be debated in the Lords on Wednesday.

Fletcher-Vane, who travels by train to the Lords most weeks, took his seat in 1989 after he became 2nd Baron Inglewood on the death of his father.

He served as a junior minister for the Conservatives in the mid-1990s and is a former member of the European Parliament.

The 73-year-old now sits as an independent cross-bencher.

At Hutton-in-the-Forest, where 500-year-old tapestries adorn the walls, Fletcher-Vane acknowledged that peerages by birthright are anachronistic in today's world.

But he also defended the contribution of many hereditary peers, some of whose titles have been in their family for centuries.

- 'I've had an ordinary life' -

"I've always tried to take it seriously," Fletcher-Vane said, claiming to be "a voice" for the north of England.

The Lords, whose primary role is to scrutinise government legislation, comprises around 800 members, most of whom are appointed for life by outgoing prime ministers, sometimes as a less-than-subtle reward for political loyalty.

Members include former MPs, people nominated after serving in prominent public- or private-sector roles and senior Church of England clerics.

John Attlee, the 2nd Earl Attlee and grandson of former Labour prime minister Clement Attlee, is another hereditary peer preparing to hand back the red ermine-clad robes adorned by lords.

He entered the chamber in 1992 after a career in road transport operations and as a member of the British Army's volunteer reserve force.

"Because I've had an ordinary life, I have experience and knowledge that others, or very few others have in parliament," the 68-year-old told AFP over coffee in the Lords' guest room.

- 'Life beyond' the Lords -

Prime Minister Keir Starmer's party, which in July returned to power for the first time in 14 years, is resurrecting reforms begun under Tony Blair's Labour government in the late 1990s.

Blair had intended to abolish all the seats held by hundreds of hereditary members who sat in the chamber at that time. But he ended up retaining 92 in what was supposed to be a temporary compromise.

"Reform of the House of Lords has been on the political agenda on and off to some extent for well over a century," Daniel Gover, a constitutional expert at Queen Mary University of London, told AFP.

That led hereditary peers to feel for decades that they were on borrowed time.

"I always expected that the system would have been changed before my turn came," Attlee said.

But reform has proven to be a thorny issue for successive administrations, in part because officials have struggled to propose better alternatives.

The government says it wants to ultimately replace the Lords with an alternative second chamber more representative of the UK.

But campaign groups such as the Electoral Reform Society want much wider reforms.

It notes that the Lords is "the second-largest legislative chamber in the world after China's National People's Congress", and calls for a "smaller, elected house" to work alongside the elected Commons.

Some peers are criticised for rarely turning up. Those who do are eligible to claim a daily allowance of up to 361 pounds ($460) plus travel expenses.

Fletcher-Vane said he thinks scrapping hereditary peers is a "crude" reform when he believes he contributes more than many life peers.

He said his last day, likely next year, will be a "sad" one, but not completely unfamiliar since he previously lost a European Parliament seat.

"I've been through it all before and there's life beyond it," he said.

M.Ito--JT