The Japan Times - Why did a Dominican nightclub roof cave in?

EUR -
AED 4.031105
AFN 70.793813
ALL 89.9812
AMD 396.184729
ANG 1.96523
AOA 1007.63949
ARS 1717.55418
AUD 1.646301
AWG 1.978508
AZN 1.867693
BAM 1.953827
BBD 2.211676
BDT 136.5821
BGN 1.946644
BHD 0.414384
BIF 3298.499713
BMD 1.097647
BND 1.416083
BOB 12.909084
BRL 6.488078
BSD 1.098046
BTN 102.375449
BWP 15.511692
BYN 3.28365
BYR 21513.876468
BZD 2.20858
CAD 1.572961
CDF 2508.122784
CHF 0.926205
CLF 0.028229
CLP 1111.00488
CNY 7.318889
CNH 7.345095
COP 3776.190238
CRC 491.583518
CUC 1.097647
CUP 26.35539
CVE 110.153783
CZK 24.438051
DJF 195.074061
DKK 7.473788
DOP 66.100552
DZD 150.50057
EGP 59.076995
ERN 16.464701
ETB 180.241661
FJD 2.508997
FKP 0.834629
GBP 0.838015
GEL 2.843044
GGP 0.834629
GHS 12.909084
GIP 0.834629
GMD 80.67201
GNF 9735.170864
GTQ 8.39518
GYD 229.63735
HKD 8.60729
HNL 29.519196
HRK 7.499084
HTG 143.975946
HUF 373.247141
IDR 20058.396866
ILS 3.621032
IMP 0.834629
INR 102.527946
IQD 1664.819112
IRR 2121931.748852
ISK 137.194633
JEP 0.834629
JMD 173.794528
JOD 0.778232
JPY 175.364986
KES 142.748763
KGS 95.989408
KHR 4468.203719
KMF 492.843083
KPW 987.882467
KRW 1463.87689
KWD 0.342411
KYD 0.915197
KZT 494.403077
LAK 24743.243351
LBP 98343.303417
LKR 365.505982
LRD 184.451
LSL 18.917924
LTL 3.241065
LVL 0.663955
LYD 7.106825
MAD 10.920974
MDL 20.151113
MGA 4958.039275
MKD 61.527632
MMK 2304.840208
MNT 3952.42187
MOP 8.873177
MRU 44.792938
MUR 51.413517
MVR 16.929753
MWK 1903.839562
MXN 20.89307
MYR 4.514653
MZN 70.141485
NAD 18.918699
NGN 1482.812368
NIO 40.407546
NOK 10.722401
NPR 163.83108
NZD 1.997036
OMR 0.422031
PAB 1.098201
PEN 3.746963
PGK 4.940012
PHP 70.095492
PKR 303.541285
PLN 4.438697
PYG 6885.048496
QAR 3.991969
RON 5.348284
RSD 117.638093
RUB 90.197879
RWF 1625.296034
SAR 4.11999
SBD 8.931597
SCR 15.332323
SDG 660.232421
SEK 11.181267
SGD 1.417924
SHP 0.831047
SLE 25.027274
SLL 23017.107726
SOS 627.572088
SRD 41.008344
STD 22719.071762
STN 24.474286
SVC 9.608299
SYP 14271.603525
SZL 18.914076
THB 37.258482
TJS 10.101107
TMT 3.841764
TND 3.32744
TOP 2.64287
TRY 55.394279
TTD 7.451511
TWD 36.262987
TZS 2919.72387
UAH 49.469153
UGX 4650.30481
USD 1.097647
UYU 44.574995
UZS 13155.717301
VES 1006.133698
VND 28269.892267
VUV 132.759411
WST 3.098966
XAF 655.957
XAG 0.024707
XAU 0.000298495419
XCD 2.966445
XCG 1.979111
XDR 0.776093
XOF 655.957
XPF 119.331742
YER 259.648451
ZAR 19.191368
ZMK 9880.146255
ZMW 22.56742
ZWL 353.441808
SSP 6453.723109
MXV 2.342656
  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    19.81

    +0.5%

  • VOD

    -0.2500

    16.33

    -1.53%

  • CMSC

    -0.2800

    20.12

    -1.39%

  • RBGPF

    -2.0000

    65

    -3.08%

  • RIO

    -0.2500

    94.16

    -0.27%

  • BTI

    -1.2000

    54.85

    -2.19%

  • NGG

    -0.3000

    74.94

    -0.4%

  • GSK

    -0.3500

    49.35

    -0.71%

  • BCE

    -0.4200

    20.14

    -2.09%

  • CMSD

    -0.3400

    19.93

    -1.71%

  • BP

    -0.9100

    43.52

    -2.09%

  • RELX

    0.1700

    33.24

    +0.51%

  • BCC

    -0.6200

    75.97

    -0.82%

  • AZN

    -1.9400

    164.21

    -1.18%

  • JRI

    0.0000

    10.77

    0%

Why did a Dominican nightclub roof cave in?
Why did a Dominican nightclub roof cave in? / Photo: Alfred DAVIES - AFP

Why did a Dominican nightclub roof cave in?

The government of the Dominican Republic has vowed an exhaustive investigation into why the roof of a nightclub caved in on revellers, killing more than 200.

Text size:

Experts, meanwhile, said the causes appear to be clear: insufficient support for too heavy a structure also weakened by a fire almost two years ago.

Video footage of the last moments before the roof of the Jet Set club came crashing down in the wee hours of Tuesday showed people leaving the venue in a rain of dust from above.

Survivor Iris Pena told local television she made for the door after dirt started falling into her drink and a stone fell and cracked the table she had been sitting at.

Another video showed the stage with merengue performer Rubby Perez singing to an adoring crowd as someone comments that a piece of slab had fallen down.

The videos end in darkness, crashing sounds and screams.

- Overloaded? -

The Jet Set nightclub was 52 years old, and operated in a building originally constructed to house a cinema.

Standing two floors high, with walls painted black, it featured a large hall with a spacious dance floor adorned with disco balls, large, heavy speakers and light fixtures.

It could host 700 people seated at tables, and 1,000 standing.

An aerial view of the disaster site shows air conditioning machines and power generators weighing tons lying among the roof rubble.

"Imagine you put two or three 42.5-kilogram (93.7-pound) cement bags on your head... your feet are not going to hold," explained Persio Diaz, a civil engineering professor at the Autonomous University of Santo Domingo, adding: "the supports were not sufficient to withstand the loads."

He added: "If you overload a structure, it will not support you."

Architect Garivalddy De Aza analyzed photos of the roof slab on Instagram, and observed "not a single column to relieve the load" of the structure.

"The roof collapsed under its own weight," he concluded.

- Fire damage? -

In 2023, a fire broke out at the nightclub after lighting struck. Firefighters who put out the blaze said at the time the building's integrity had not been compromised.

But Diaz said that "when a structure like that is affected by a severe fire, the durability of the concrete... deteriorates significantly" and it "turns into a kind of weak concrete."

He also pointed out that steel corrodes with time, and the high humidity in the Caribbean country can affect the soundness of building materials over time.

De Aza said there appeared to have been "a lack of planning in the building's growth."

Juan Villar Gonzalez, a former president of the Dominican College of Engineers, Architects and Surveyors, said the building also lacked circulation and emergency doors.

"There has been little supervision," noted Villar, adding the tragedy needed to be studied in detail and lessons learnt to prevent another in future.

The Jet Set said Tuesday it was working "fully and transparently" with authorities investigating the calamity.

S.Fujimoto--JT