The Japan Times - France tightens infant formula rules after toxin scare

The infant formula industry has been rocked by several firms recalling batches that could be contaminated with cereulide, which can cause nausea, vomiting, and diarrhoea.

French authorities launched an investigation into the deaths in December and January of two babies who were thought to have drunk possibly contaminated powdered milk.

At this stage investigators have not established a direct link between the symptoms and the milk consumed.

The recalls have raised fresh questions about food safety challenges in the global supply chain.

There is no established safety limit for cereulide in infant formula.

"Protecting the health of infants is the top priority for health authorities," the French agriculture ministry said late Friday.

The new threshold will be 0.014 micrograms of cereulide per kilogram of body weight, compared to 0.03 micrograms currently, it said.

This is the second lowering of a threshold in France in less than two weeks.

The recall of potentially contaminated infant formula has heaped scrutiny on Chinese firm Cabio Biotech, the supplier of an ingredient used in infant formula which is suspected of being tainted.

Headquartered in the central Chinese city of Wuhan, Cabio Biotech is one of the world's largest producers of ARA, a fatty acid used primarily in baby formula and food products.

The French authorities have referred to a single "Chinese supplier" without naming it.

This week the European Commission asked the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) to establish a standard for cereulide in children's products.

It will issue an opinion on February 2.

The European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control said it had received reports of diarrhoea cases in infants following consumption of the products in question, but "no severe cases have been reported".

- Lawsuit -

Several manufacturers, including European giants like Nestle, Danone, and Lactalis, have issued recalls of infant formula in France and dozens of countries since December.

The toxin is rare and difficult to detect, and some recalls have been carried out as a precaution, some manufacturers said.

On Thursday, Nestle provided a detailed timeline of its recalls, acknowledging that around 10 days had passed between the first detection of cereulide in late November and the first recalls on December 10.

The Swiss food conglomerate argued that, in the absence of "European regulations on the presence of cereulide in food", it had followed standard procedures.

The detection led to the precautionary recall of all products in contact with the production line where cereulide had been detected.

The group stressed that it was the first company to detect the problem.

Foodwatch, a European consumer association, has filed a lawsuit accusing manufacturers and the government of acting too slowly.

Eight French families, who said their babies suffered severe digestive problems after drinking formula named in the recall, have joined the lawsuit.

On Friday, Nestle refuted the accusations made by the watchdog, saying it reserved the right to respond in court "if Foodwatch continues to disseminate misleading information".

"Testing for bacteria of the Bacillus cereus family is routinely offered," Francois Vigneau of lab testing firm Eurofins said last week. He added however that tests for cereulide were "not part of standard checks".

"In the current context of milk recalls, this test is currently being requested because all stakeholders in dairy products in general, and infant formula in particular, are concerned about the situation," added Vigneau.

According to World Health Organisation estimates from 2019, 23 million people in Europe fall sick from eating contaminated food every year, and an estimated 4,700 people die.

S.Yamada--JT