The Japan Times - Under pressure? EU states on edge over migrant burden-sharing

The 27-nation European Union adopted a sweeping overhaul of its migration policies in 2024, soon to come into force.

A key element is a new "solidarity" system for managing asylum seekers, aimed at easing the burden on frontline countries such as Spain, Greece and Italy.

The idea is broadly speaking to sort member states into different categories:

-- Those deemed by Brussels to be under "migratory pressure", based on criteria such as the number of irregular arrivals and sea rescue operations.

-- Other countries, which will be required to either take in a share of asylum seekers from countries under pressure, or provide them with financial support amounting to 20,000 euros ($23,000) per person.

- Feeling the pressure -

There the trouble begins: how to decide who qualifies as "under pressure".

"You can see in the political rhetoric that everyone feels that they are under migratory pressure," said a source within the European Commission, which is tasked with sorting countries into categories.

Member states are lobbying hard to influence the methodology used.

In recent days, for instance, Sweden has pointed to the 300,000 asylum applications it received over the past decade as a high figure for a "medium-size country".

Belgium highlights that its migrant "reception centres are full", while Germany has stressed it has taken in more than a million Ukrainian refugees since Russia's invasion in 2022.

France, meanwhile, has underscored its maritime rescue operations for migrants attempting to cross the Channel to Britain.

The commission is expected to unveil its proposal next week, following nearly a month of delays.

That will form the basis for negotiations among member states on how many additional asylum seekers each is willing to accept -- or how much financial support they are ready to offer.

At least 30,000 migrants will need relocating each year under the new system, with a decision on who goes where required by the end of December.

- 'Tricky balance' -

But with governments across the bloc under pressure to tighten immigration policies, putting a hand up to take in extra asylum seekers is fraught with political risk.

"It's an extremely tricky balance to strike," said Camille Le Coz, head of the Migration Policy Institute Europe think tank.

All the more so because "countries don't trust each other on this question," she told AFP.

Several states -- including Germany, Belgium and The Netherlands -- accuse frontline countries of allowing migrants to move on into the bloc, rather than processing their asylum claims as required under EU law.

Frontline countries tend to reject the charge.

"The Germans are on edge -- there are tensions with the Italians and the Greeks over this file," said an EU diplomat, granted anonymity to discuss the sensitive matter.

"It's not easy, because everyone is watching one another and wondering: 'Will the other member state end up with a better deal?'" he said.

K.Tanaka--JT