The Japan Times - Renewable energy in the dock in Spain after blackout

EUR -
AED 4.033233
AFN 70.832917
ALL 90.300515
AMD 393.066954
ANG 1.966265
AOA 1008.170872
ARS 1704.735421
AUD 1.634069
AWG 1.976805
AZN 1.865603
BAM 1.953621
BBD 2.211224
BDT 137.127053
BGN 1.94767
BHD 0.414236
BIF 3301.402687
BMD 1.098225
BND 1.414915
BOB 12.806716
BRL 6.345768
BSD 1.09789
BTN 102.562671
BWP 15.367929
BYN 3.2948
BYR 21525.211443
BZD 2.208127
CAD 1.572054
CDF 2519.328333
CHF 0.923721
CLF 0.027742
CLP 1091.844327
CNY 7.320933
CNH 7.321405
COP 3634.048733
CRC 489.0523
CUC 1.098225
CUP 26.34961
CVE 110.143654
CZK 24.362976
DJF 195.511043
DKK 7.474333
DOP 66.485541
DZD 150.595324
EGP 58.9995
ERN 16.473376
ETB 180.196412
FJD 2.52361
FKP 0.830897
GBP 0.832487
GEL 2.84458
GGP 0.830897
GHS 12.88322
GIP 0.830897
GMD 81.268607
GNF 9727.1064
GTQ 8.390756
GYD 229.586609
HKD 8.616592
HNL 29.516943
HRK 7.503035
HTG 143.837603
HUF 367.015286
IDR 20059.080969
ILS 3.574822
IMP 0.830897
INR 102.562086
IQD 1664.428392
IRR 2118534.939608
ISK 136.806345
JEP 0.830897
JMD 174.464613
JOD 0.778629
JPY 174.916534
KES 142.824157
KGS 96.038643
KHR 4478.94315
KMF 492.004305
KPW 988.402951
KRW 1464.192117
KWD 0.342141
KYD 0.914971
KZT 487.441884
LAK 24727.419798
LBP 98319.17596
LKR 365.322531
LRD 184.442599
LSL 18.574267
LTL 3.242773
LVL 0.664305
LYD 7.095054
MAD 10.957778
MDL 20.103035
MGA 4994.383941
MKD 61.554724
MMK 2305.599623
MNT 3961.026963
MOP 8.873224
MRU 44.487178
MUR 52.648829
MVR 16.915638
MWK 1903.759271
MXN 20.263554
MYR 4.530728
MZN 70.172768
NAD 18.574014
NGN 1483.976329
NIO 40.40475
NOK 10.589751
NPR 164.101219
NZD 2.000629
OMR 0.422258
PAB 1.097875
PEN 3.749618
PGK 4.939423
PHP 69.951403
PKR 303.54618
PLN 4.404712
PYG 6840.339354
QAR 4.002291
RON 5.349123
RSD 117.633132
RUB 90.272028
RWF 1624.872871
SAR 4.130319
SBD 8.936303
SCR 15.209278
SDG 660.582753
SEK 11.140785
SGD 1.416299
SHP 0.831485
SLE 25.037179
SLL 23029.234705
SOS 627.397364
SRD 41.115348
STD 22731.041716
STN 24.47237
SVC 9.606198
SYP 14279.122777
SZL 18.57237
THB 37.218996
TJS 10.11707
TMT 3.843788
TND 3.32234
TOP 2.644263
TRY 55.395758
TTD 7.433641
TWD 36.182784
TZS 2910.294205
UAH 49.769735
UGX 4555.77344
USD 1.098225
UYU 44.600051
UZS 13194.283503
VES 1005.427142
VND 28204.067228
VUV 132.956262
WST 3.100598
XAF 655.957
XAG 0.023863
XAU 0.000290025121
XCD 2.968008
XCG 1.978675
XDR 0.776502
XOF 655.957
XPF 119.331742
YER 259.785175
ZAR 18.643691
ZMK 9885.337365
ZMW 22.490812
ZWL 353.628026
SSP 6511.055256
MXV 2.272663
  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    19.81

    +0.5%

  • VOD

    -0.2500

    16.33

    -1.53%

  • CMSC

    -0.2800

    20.12

    -1.39%

  • RBGPF

    -2.0000

    65

    -3.08%

  • RIO

    -0.2500

    94.16

    -0.27%

  • BTI

    -1.2000

    54.85

    -2.19%

  • NGG

    -0.3000

    74.94

    -0.4%

  • GSK

    -0.3500

    49.35

    -0.71%

  • BCE

    -0.4200

    20.14

    -2.09%

  • CMSD

    -0.3400

    19.93

    -1.71%

  • BP

    -0.9100

    43.52

    -2.09%

  • RELX

    0.1700

    33.24

    +0.51%

  • BCC

    -0.6200

    75.97

    -0.82%

  • AZN

    -1.9400

    164.21

    -1.18%

  • JRI

    0.0000

    10.77

    0%

Renewable energy in the dock in Spain after blackout
Renewable energy in the dock in Spain after blackout / Photo: CESAR MANSO - AFP

Renewable energy in the dock in Spain after blackout

Fierce debate raged in Spain on Wednesday over the role its reliance on renewable energy may have had in this week's blackout which disrupted millions of lives, though officials sought to downplay any potential link.

Text size:

"The lack of nuclear power stations and the 'boom' in renewables have brought the electricity grid to its knees," conservative newspaper ABC headlined on its front page.

Rival daily El Mundo wrote that "warnings about renewables over the last five years" had been "ignored".

Conservative opposition parties have also questioned Socialist Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez's push to make Spain a green energy champion in the wake of Monday's power outage which halted trains, trapped people in elevators and plunged cities into darkness in the country and neighbouring Portugal.

Solar and wind power accounted for almost 40 percent of Spain's electricity last year, twice as much as in 2014, according to electricity operator REE.

By contrast the share of electricity generated by nuclear power fell to 20 percent in 2024, with the government aiming to phase out its atomic power plants by 2035.

Questions about the resilience of this mix began to be raised after it emerged that REE's parent company, Redeia, warned in its 2024 financial report that "the high penetration of renewable generation without the necessary technical capacity to deal adequately with disturbances" could "lead to production cuts".

These blackouts "could become severe, even leading to an imbalance between production and demand, which would significantly affect the electricity supply", it added in the report published in February.

- 'Worked perfectly' -

This message was echoed in a January report by Spain's competition watchdog CNMC which said the voltage on the electricity grid had sometimes "reached maximum values close to the authorised thresholds, and have even exceeded them at certain times".

After the blackout, experts questioned if an imbalance between electricity production and demand -- which is harder to correct without the right technology in a grid with significant wind and solar power generation -- could have led to the collapse of the system.

But Redeia president Beatriz Corredor -- a former Socialist lawmaker -- said renewable energy production "is secure", adding during an interview with news radio Cadena Ser on Wednesday it was "wrong" to link it to the blackout.

Redeia's 380-page annual financial report was merely listing a series of potential risks as required by law, she said.

Asked about the controversy, Ecological Transition Minister Sara Aagesen said Wednesday the cause of the blackout was still unknown and it was "imprudent to speculate".

"The system has worked perfectly well with similar demand and a comparable energy mix. Consequently, pointing the finger at renewables... does not seem appropriate," she added, calling Spain's network "robust".

- 'Ignorance' -

Sanchez on Tuesday defended his government's energy model and stressed that the cause of the outage was not yet known.

"Those who link this incident to the lack of nuclear power are frankly lying or demonstrating their ignorance," he told a news conference.

"Nuclear power plants, far from being a solution, have been a problem" during the blackout because "it was necessary to divert large amounts of energy to them to keep their cores stable", Sanchez said.

Spain's electricity network lost 15 gigawatts of electricity generation -- the equivalent of 60 percent of the country's electricity consumption at the time -- in just five seconds on Monday at around 12:33 pm (1033 GMT).

Spain's top criminal court said Tuesday it is investigating whether the blackout was "an act of computer sabotage" but REE has ruled out a cyberattack.

It has instead identified as a possible cause of the blackout two separate incidents just one and a half seconds apart, one which may have affected solar power production in southwest Spain.

But REE stressed it is "not possible to draw any conclusions" at this stage.

T.Shimizu--JT