The Japan Times - China deploys army of fake NGOs at UN to intimidate critics: media probe

EUR -
AED 4.025853
AFN 70.70607
ALL 90.135238
AMD 392.347525
ANG 1.962667
AOA 1006.325218
ARS 1701.579884
AUD 1.63045
AWG 1.973187
AZN 1.866058
BAM 1.950045
BBD 2.207176
BDT 136.87607
BGN 1.944105
BHD 0.413478
BIF 3295.360143
BMD 1.096215
BND 1.412326
BOB 12.783276
BRL 6.344674
BSD 1.095881
BTN 102.374951
BWP 15.339801
BYN 3.28877
BYR 21485.813938
BZD 2.204086
CAD 1.570661
CDF 2514.71741
CHF 0.922723
CLF 0.027694
CLP 1089.977209
CNY 7.307534
CNH 7.307813
COP 3627.397349
CRC 488.157189
CUC 1.096215
CUP 26.301383
CVE 109.942058
CZK 24.393197
DJF 195.1532
DKK 7.474926
DOP 66.363853
DZD 150.403946
EGP 58.980318
ERN 16.443225
ETB 179.8666
FJD 2.518997
FKP 0.829376
GBP 0.833534
GEL 2.838907
GGP 0.829376
GHS 12.85964
GIP 0.829376
GMD 81.120219
GNF 9709.302918
GTQ 8.375398
GYD 229.166398
HKD 8.600875
HNL 29.462919
HRK 7.489302
HTG 143.574338
HUF 367.668868
IDR 19990.576682
ILS 3.565116
IMP 0.829376
INR 102.497582
IQD 1661.381996
IRR 2114657.375626
ISK 136.809695
JEP 0.829376
JMD 174.145291
JOD 0.777232
JPY 174.515782
KES 142.56241
KGS 95.862891
KHR 4470.745359
KMF 491.104327
KPW 986.593881
KRW 1459.577857
KWD 0.341581
KYD 0.913296
KZT 486.549721
LAK 24682.161305
LBP 98139.222783
LKR 364.653882
LRD 184.105014
LSL 18.540271
LTL 3.236838
LVL 0.663089
LYD 7.082068
MAD 10.937722
MDL 20.066241
MGA 4985.242741
MKD 61.494975
MMK 2301.379694
MNT 3953.777112
MOP 8.856984
MRU 44.405753
MUR 52.552826
MVR 16.867619
MWK 1900.274828
MXN 20.286448
MYR 4.515412
MZN 70.05605
NAD 18.540018
NGN 1482.838864
NIO 40.330797
NOK 10.631795
NPR 163.800866
NZD 1.998049
OMR 0.42148
PAB 1.095866
PEN 3.742755
PGK 4.930383
PHP 69.901794
PKR 302.990601
PLN 4.408604
PYG 6827.819509
QAR 3.994965
RON 5.349425
RSD 117.638122
RUB 90.023757
RWF 1621.898873
SAR 4.122759
SBD 8.919947
SCR 15.177992
SDG 659.371235
SEK 11.142171
SGD 1.413936
SHP 0.829963
SLE 25.012244
SLL 22987.084393
SOS 626.249041
SRD 41.040045
STD 22689.437185
STN 24.427578
SVC 9.588616
SYP 14252.987758
SZL 18.538377
THB 37.239495
TJS 10.098552
TMT 3.836752
TND 3.316259
TOP 2.639423
TRY 55.296236
TTD 7.420035
TWD 36.109616
TZS 2896.748604
UAH 49.678642
UGX 4547.435027
USD 1.096215
UYU 44.51842
UZS 13170.134061
VES 1003.586913
VND 28200.130794
VUV 132.712913
WST 3.094923
XAF 655.957
XAG 0.023948
XAU 0.000290518908
XCD 2.962576
XCG 1.975053
XDR 0.775081
XOF 655.957
XPF 119.331742
YER 259.30992
ZAR 18.709995
ZMK 9867.247522
ZMW 22.449647
ZWL 352.980782
SSP 6499.138099
MXV 2.27523
  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    19.81

    +0.5%

  • VOD

    -0.2500

    16.33

    -1.53%

  • CMSC

    -0.2800

    20.12

    -1.39%

  • RBGPF

    -2.0000

    65

    -3.08%

  • RIO

    -0.2500

    94.16

    -0.27%

  • BTI

    -1.2000

    54.85

    -2.19%

  • NGG

    -0.3000

    74.94

    -0.4%

  • GSK

    -0.3500

    49.35

    -0.71%

  • BCE

    -0.4200

    20.14

    -2.09%

  • CMSD

    -0.3400

    19.93

    -1.71%

  • BP

    -0.9100

    43.52

    -2.09%

  • RELX

    0.1700

    33.24

    +0.51%

  • BCC

    -0.6200

    75.97

    -0.82%

  • AZN

    -1.9400

    164.21

    -1.18%

  • JRI

    0.0000

    10.77

    0%

China deploys army of fake NGOs at UN to intimidate critics: media probe
China deploys army of fake NGOs at UN to intimidate critics: media probe / Photo: Fabrice COFFRINI - AFP

China deploys army of fake NGOs at UN to intimidate critics: media probe

China is deploying a growing army of organisations masquerading as NGOs to monitor and intimidate rights activists at the UN, a new investigation by the ICIJ media consortium said on Monday.

Text size:

Dubbed "China Targets", the fresh investigation involving 42 media organisations delves into the various tactics Beijing uses to silence critics beyond its borders.

One segment of the probe published by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists (ICIJ) deals with China's increasing offensive at the United Nations Human Rights Council in Geneva.

In particular, it focuses on the growing presence at the council of pro-China, government-organised non-governmental organisations, referred to as "Gongos".

Such groups crowd into council sessions to praise China and present glowing accounts of its actions that are largely at odds with UN and expert findings of widespread rights violations and repression.

A bombshell report published by former UN rights chief Michelle Bachelet in 2022 for instance cited possible "crimes against humanity" against China's Uyghur minority in the western Xinjiang region.

Other reports have highlighted the separation of Tibetan children from their families and the targeting of democracy activists in Hong Kong.

But when legitimate NGOs raise such issues at the council, Gongos often strive to disrupt the session and drown out their testimonies, the ICIJ said.

- 'Corrosive' -

An ICIJ analysis of 106 NGOs from mainland China, Hong Kong, Macau and Taiwan registered with the UN found that 59 had close links to the government in Beijing or the Chinese Communist Party.

During a regular review of China's rights record before the council last year, attended by AFP, more than half of the NGOs granted a speaking slot were pro-government groups.

"It's corrosive. It's dishonest," Michele Taylor, who served as US ambassador to the Human Rights Council from 2022 until January this year, was quoted as saying in the report.

She decried a broader effort by Beijing "to obfuscate their own human rights violations and reshape the narrative".

Increasingly, the Beijing-controlled groups are also used to monitor and intimidate those planning to testify about alleged abuses, the investigation found.

The ICIJ and its partners said they spoke with 15 activists and lawyers focused on rights issues in China who "described being surveilled or harassed by people suspected to be proxies for the Chinese government".

Such incidents occurred both inside the UN and elsewhere in Geneva.

- 'We're watching' -

The report highlighted how a group of Chinese activists and dissidents were so fearful of Beijing's swelling presence at the council that they in March last year refused to set foot inside the UN buildings.

"Instead, they gathered for a secret meeting on the top floor of a nondescript office building nearby" with UN rights chief Volker Turk, the report said.

But suddenly, four people claiming to work with the Guangdong Human rights Association showed up asking about the meeting, to which they had not been invited.

Staff from the International Service for Human Rights (ISHR) who were facilitating the meeting denied it was taking place.

The four left, but later, when two Uyghur participants left the office for a smoke, they reported that someone in a black car with tinted windows photographed them before people matching the description of the Guangdong group got into the vehicle and it pulled away.

Zumretay Arkin, vice president of the World Uyghur Congress, told ICIJ she believed the Guangdong group was sending a message from Beijing: "We're watching you... You can't escape us."

- 'Deadly reprisal' -

The activists had reason to be fearful.

Over a decade ago, activist Cao Shunli was detained as she attempted to travel to Geneva ahead of a China rights record review at the UN.

After being held for several months without charge, she fell gravely ill and died on March 14, 2014.

ICIJ said her death "stood out as a powerful warning shot", determining that the "deadly reprisal" had discouraged other activists from engaging with the UN.

A decade later, Chinese rights defenders are participating in UN activities at record low numbers, the investigation found.

At the same time, the number of Chinese NGOs registered with the UN has nearly doubled since 2018, it said.

Y.Kimura--JT