The Japan Times - 'I don't have a voice in my head': Life with no inner monologue

EUR -
AED 4.030253
AFN 70.771844
ALL 89.950576
AMD 396.049299
ANG 1.964561
AOA 1007.297087
ARS 1717.08485
AUD 1.647335
AWG 1.975092
AZN 1.865972
BAM 1.953162
BBD 2.210924
BDT 136.535616
BGN 1.945982
BHD 0.413946
BIF 3297.305934
BMD 1.097273
BND 1.415601
BOB 12.90469
BRL 6.513192
BSD 1.097673
BTN 102.340607
BWP 15.506413
BYN 3.282532
BYR 21506.554514
BZD 2.207829
CAD 1.57445
CDF 2501.782932
CHF 0.926153
CLF 0.0283
CLP 1113.797734
CNY 7.315136
CNH 7.344631
COP 3760.761211
CRC 491.416215
CUC 1.097273
CUP 26.346421
CVE 110.577679
CZK 24.44055
DJF 195.007314
DKK 7.474312
DOP 66.057702
DZD 150.479012
EGP 59.05897
ERN 16.459098
ETB 180.180318
FJD 2.51731
FKP 0.834345
GBP 0.837861
GEL 2.842031
GGP 0.834345
GHS 12.920365
GIP 0.834345
GMD 81.197591
GNF 9721.840519
GTQ 8.392322
GYD 229.559196
HKD 8.604882
HNL 29.509149
HRK 7.496532
HTG 143.926946
HUF 373.285726
IDR 20052.667538
ILS 3.6198
IMP 0.834345
INR 102.400552
IQD 1664.252513
IRR 2125763.257256
ISK 137.20265
JEP 0.834345
JMD 173.735379
JOD 0.777935
JPY 175.204872
KES 142.722116
KGS 95.956622
KHR 4471.388232
KMF 492.675606
KPW 987.546255
KRW 1465.013367
KWD 0.341767
KYD 0.914885
KZT 494.234814
LAK 24721.564941
LBP 98260.813999
LKR 365.381587
LRD 184.388225
LSL 18.911485
LTL 3.239962
LVL 0.663729
LYD 7.104406
MAD 10.917257
MDL 20.144255
MGA 4956.351874
MKD 61.540316
MMK 2304.055787
MNT 3951.076717
MOP 8.870158
MRU 44.777694
MUR 51.396627
MVR 16.895038
MWK 1903.191616
MXN 20.942584
MYR 4.512867
MZN 70.111302
NAD 18.91226
NGN 1482.302958
NIO 40.393794
NOK 10.718899
NPR 163.775322
NZD 2.00073
OMR 0.421892
PAB 1.097827
PEN 3.745688
PGK 4.938331
PHP 70.049571
PKR 303.437979
PLN 4.438508
PYG 6882.705264
QAR 3.990611
RON 5.34808
RSD 117.631017
RUB 90.170062
RWF 1624.742887
SAR 4.118588
SBD 8.928557
SCR 15.205441
SDG 660.013387
SEK 11.188477
SGD 1.417655
SHP 0.830764
SLE 25.015602
SLL 23009.274168
SOS 627.358502
SRD 40.99424
STD 22711.339636
STN 24.465957
SVC 9.605029
SYP 14266.746379
SZL 18.907639
THB 37.284801
TJS 10.097669
TMT 3.840456
TND 3.326308
TOP 2.641971
TRY 55.366633
TTD 7.448974
TWD 36.240741
TZS 2918.730213
UAH 49.452317
UGX 4648.722142
USD 1.097273
UYU 44.559824
UZS 13151.239933
VES 1005.791274
VND 28260.270995
VUV 132.714229
WST 3.097911
XAF 655.957
XAG 0.024983
XAU 0.000299689239
XCD 2.965435
XCG 1.978437
XDR 0.775829
XOF 655.957
XPF 119.331742
YER 259.559968
ZAR 19.197381
ZMK 9876.783748
ZMW 22.55974
ZWL 353.321519
SSP 6451.526672
MXV 2.348208
  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    19.81

    +0.5%

  • VOD

    -0.2500

    16.33

    -1.53%

  • CMSC

    -0.2800

    20.12

    -1.39%

  • RBGPF

    -2.0000

    65

    -3.08%

  • RIO

    -0.2500

    94.16

    -0.27%

  • BTI

    -1.2000

    54.85

    -2.19%

  • NGG

    -0.3000

    74.94

    -0.4%

  • GSK

    -0.3500

    49.35

    -0.71%

  • BCE

    -0.4200

    20.14

    -2.09%

  • CMSD

    -0.3400

    19.93

    -1.71%

  • BP

    -0.9100

    43.52

    -2.09%

  • RELX

    0.1700

    33.24

    +0.51%

  • BCC

    -0.6200

    75.97

    -0.82%

  • AZN

    -1.9400

    164.21

    -1.18%

  • JRI

    0.0000

    10.77

    0%

'I don't have a voice in my head': Life with no inner monologue
'I don't have a voice in my head': Life with no inner monologue / Photo: Eric BARADAT - AFP/File

'I don't have a voice in my head': Life with no inner monologue

Mel May only realised she was different while reading a news article one day.

Text size:

"Wait, what? Some people hear a voice in their head?" she thought at the time.

She was stunned to discover that this was not just a figure of speech -- her friends were actually chatting to themselves in their minds.

May, a 30-year-old Australian video producer who lives in New York, remembers trying to explain to her family: "I don't have a voice in my head."

"My dad was like, 'You are lying'," she told AFP.

But her father came around once May started working with psychologists who agreed -- she is one of the very rare people who lack inner speech.

The idea that some people might not experience this phenomenon is so new that a clinical name, anendophasia, was only proposed for it in a paper last year.

The inner monologue has proven extremely difficult to study because it relies on people being able to describe how they think -- and it turns out we are unreliable narrators.

"People are ignorant about the characteristics of their own inner experience," Russell Hurlburt, a psychology professor at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas, told AFP.

"And it doesn't matter how confident you are," added Hurlburt, a pioneer in the field who has studied people with a range of inner experiences, including May.

Most people assume their inner voice is speaking all the time but it is actually just one of several phenomena of our inner experience, Hurlburt said.

Others include visual imagery, "unsymbolised thinking", feelings and sensory awareness.

- Only a quarter of the time? -

To study these phenomena, Hurlburt conducted research that would have a beeper go off at random while study participants were reading Franz Kafka's "The Metamorphosis" and describe what was in their head.

Rather than speaking the words in their inner voice, they were actually creating visual images -- "their own video" -- of the book, he said.

People also have different kinds of inner speech. Some have multiple voices, while bilingual people can switch languages.

Giordon Stark, a California-based particle physicist who was born deaf, has a mix of inner speech and visual images.

"I don't think of the word 'bed' in my head but I rather visualise the idea of my head hitting the pillow," which is similar to the sign language gesture for the word, the 34-year-old told AFP.

Pressed to estimate how often people are hearing an inner voice, Hurlburt emphasised that much more research is needed on the subject.

But a ballpark figure could be that people are "inner speaking" 20 to 25 percent of the time, he said.

That average includes people who have far more frequent speech and those with none, such as May.

"Her inner experience is close to being nothing but she's the exception rather than the rule," Hurlburt said.

Helene Loevenbruck, a leading inner voice researcher at France's Universite Grenoble Alpes, has had to change her mind on whether people like May could even exist.

"I thought everyone had an inner voice until very recently," she told AFP.

The idea ran counter to her previous work, which suggested inner speech was an important part of speaking out loud, serving as an "internal simulation".

But the work of Hurlburt -- and the discovery that some people cannot create mental images, a condition called aphantasia -- changed her mind.

- 'Pros and cons' -

May believes her lack of an inner voice is why she has never been an anxious person -- and why meditation is very easy for her.

Daniel Gregory, a philosopher specialising in inner speech at the University of Barcelona, said a potential disadvantage of having more inner speech is "a vulnerability to negative thought patterns, to rumination".

But we can also "use inner speech to encourage ourselves, to give ourselves positive messages", he told AFP.

May said a common response to hearing that she has no inner monologue is: "Wow, that must be amazing."

"I'm really quick to push back on that because I think certainly there are pros and cons," she said.

"I reflect a lot about what aspects of the lived experience I'm missing out on."

As well as not stressing about the future, May has a hard time remembering the past.

Loevenbruck said the people she had studied with aphantasia reported having "weird" autobiographical memories "because they have no sensory way of reliving a memory".

May emphasised that lacking an inner voice did not mean she was incapable of thought.

"I'm not dead inside. I know stuff and I feel stuff," said May, who plans to make a documentary about her experience.

Asked what was running through her head, she responded simply.

"Well, I'm sitting here, I'm listening to you and then I just automatically respond. And that's it.

"Isn't that how this happens for everyone?"

S.Yamamoto--JT