The Japan Times - Looming far-right win in Germany sparks security worries

EUR -
AED 4.095701
AFN 72.480008
ALL 90.882712
AMD 401.805034
ANG 1.995737
AOA 1023.635334
ARS 1721.721299
AUD 1.622157
AWG 2.007127
AZN 1.900047
BAM 1.951697
BBD 2.245579
BDT 138.86805
BGN 1.948955
BHD 0.420772
BIF 3356.362879
BMD 1.115071
BND 1.428792
BOB 13.374482
BRL 6.138357
BSD 1.114956
BTN 104.659009
BWP 15.359741
BYN 3.339105
BYR 21855.38619
BZD 2.242466
CAD 1.573756
CDF 2586.964483
CHF 0.914881
CLF 0.027698
CLP 1090.127033
CNY 7.444774
CNH 7.440667
COP 3625.685911
CRC 505.646021
CUC 1.115071
CUP 26.76054
CVE 110.842372
CZK 24.346956
DJF 198.170808
DKK 7.480457
DOP 67.740985
DZD 152.081196
EGP 59.957114
ERN 16.726061
ETB 179.75372
FJD 2.514764
FKP 0.826997
GBP 0.834821
GEL 2.893653
GGP 0.826997
GHS 13.029646
GIP 0.826997
GMD 83.077063
GNF 9876.743229
GTQ 8.520088
GYD 233.749058
HKD 8.744552
HNL 30.190584
HRK 7.547925
HTG 146.132606
HUF 363.51345
IDR 20192.258205
ILS 3.552538
IMP 0.826997
INR 104.869336
IQD 1688.217076
IRR 2108992.359359
ISK 136.919964
JEP 0.826997
JMD 176.947992
JOD 0.790629
JPY 176.744329
KES 144.903869
KGS 97.510486
KHR 4549.488945
KMF 492.86165
KPW 1003.563608
KRW 1520.737678
KWD 0.346765
KYD 0.929309
KZT 499.776184
LAK 25094.667032
LBP 99854.583719
LKR 370.763872
LRD 189.90075
LSL 18.465996
LTL 3.292514
LVL 0.674496
LYD 7.170329
MAD 10.880307
MDL 19.93044
MGA 5123.750363
MKD 61.556144
MMK 2341.596043
MNT 4016.453808
MOP 9.000882
MRU 44.882019
MUR 52.442198
MVR 17.176258
MWK 1936.878232
MXN 20.768572
MYR 4.528864
MZN 71.257178
NAD 18.465992
NGN 1502.23485
NIO 40.823159
NOK 10.548462
NPR 167.454215
NZD 2.010586
OMR 0.428348
PAB 1.115031
PEN 3.838635
PGK 5.008941
PHP 70.369926
PKR 308.456482
PLN 4.399568
PYG 6968.50605
QAR 4.062245
RON 5.343646
RSD 117.7359
RUB 91.352798
RWF 1644.729318
SAR 4.18675
SBD 8.974739
SCR 15.631155
SDG 670.719139
SEK 11.033072
SGD 1.430194
SHP 0.835103
SLE 25.591287
SLL 23382.48045
SOS 637.267002
SRD 41.908265
STD 23079.712667
STN 24.8382
SVC 9.75549
SYP 14498.149201
SZL 18.465983
THB 37.411034
TJS 10.285553
TMT 3.902748
TND 3.329048
TOP 2.684822
TRY 55.9111
TTD 7.561104
TWD 36.546782
TZS 2946.578434
UAH 50.509358
UGX 4560.432794
USD 1.115071
UYU 44.855697
UZS 13380.84906
VES 999.456181
VND 28526.296796
VUV 133.26585
WST 3.098241
XAF 655.957
XAG 0.021465
XAU 0.000274244363
XCD 3.013535
XCG 2.009331
XDR 0.788413
XOF 655.957
XPF 119.331742
YER 263.853652
ZAR 18.419263
ZMK 10036.978597
ZMW 22.65679
ZWL 359.052318
SSP 6406.300033
MXV 2.336546
  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    19.81

    +0.5%

  • VOD

    -0.2500

    16.33

    -1.53%

  • CMSC

    -0.2800

    20.12

    -1.39%

  • RBGPF

    -2.0000

    65

    -3.08%

  • RIO

    -0.2500

    94.16

    -0.27%

  • BTI

    -1.2000

    54.85

    -2.19%

  • NGG

    -0.3000

    74.94

    -0.4%

  • GSK

    -0.3500

    49.35

    -0.71%

  • BCE

    -0.4200

    20.14

    -2.09%

  • CMSD

    -0.3400

    19.93

    -1.71%

  • BP

    -0.9100

    43.52

    -2.09%

  • RELX

    0.1700

    33.24

    +0.51%

  • BCC

    -0.6200

    75.97

    -0.82%

  • AZN

    -1.9400

    164.21

    -1.18%

  • JRI

    0.0000

    10.77

    0%

Looming far-right win in Germany sparks security worries
Looming far-right win in Germany sparks security worries / Photo: John MACDOUGALL - AFP

Looming far-right win in Germany sparks security worries

If the AfD wins key regional elections on Sunday and becomes the first far-right party in post-war Germany to form a state government, experts fear far-reaching consequences for security and defence.

Text size:

These range from potentially undermining the work of intelligence services to giving the Russia-friendly party access to sensitive information.

What would the impact be for the security apparatus?

The Alternative for Germany has pledged to overhaul the state branch of the BfV domestic intelligence agency if it wins Sunday's vote in the ex-communist, eastern state of Saxony-Anhalt.

In 2023, the agency classified the party's local chapter as a right-wing extremist organisation, a label that was later extended to the AfD nationwide. The party is challenging this decision in court.

The AfD contends the BfV is a tool used to target opponents of the establishment parties, and has even threatened to abolish it entirely if it wins an absolute majority and takes power in the state.

While they may not be able to go that far, the AfD would have room to influence the agency's work, such as by replacing top officials.

Intelligence services could also be ordered to focus more on left-wing radicalism -- which the AfD regards as "one of the greatest threats to internal security" -- rather than on right-wing extremism.

The anti-immigration party, which has threatened a "deportation and remigration offensive" targeting irregular migrants, could also shift priorities for local police so that they carry out more checks in areas home to large foreign populations.

Could the AfD get access to classified information?

National lawmaker Konstantin von Notz, vice-chairman of the German parliament's intelligence oversight committee, expects "drastic consequences for security policy" if the AfD takes power.

"Right-wing extremists with strong ties to the dictatorial regimes of this world, Russia first and foremost, could come into positions of responsibility with access to highly sensitive security-related information and databases," the Greens party MP told AFP.

Domestic intelligence services share information via internal systems on sensitive topics ranging from suspected extremists to planned attacks and so-called "hybrid threats", including from Russia.

Wolfgang Merkel, a political analyst from the WZB Berlin Social Science Center, however judged the prospect of the AfD sharing classified information with Moscow as unlikely.

Such an act would amount to "treason," he said, and also noted that "being a friend of (Russian President Vladimir) Putin is not popular in Germany, certainly not in the west, but not in the east either."

Could there be consequences for defence more broadly?

The state is home to German military bases and training areas, and Defence Minister Boris Pistorius has expressed fears about the potential consequences should the AfD get their hands on information about the sites.

He has called for AfD ministers in a state government to be barred from accessing classified information.

"We are looking intensively at the question of whom we can grant access to classified information," he told tabloid Bild. "We are obliged to do so, because it concerns the security of our country."

The Welt newspaper has reported the government is even drawing up emergency plans for a scenario in which individual states might, for example, seek to obstruct the movement of NATO troops.

How could the federal government seek to combat the AfD's more extreme plans?

In the event that a state refuses to comply with federal law, Article 37 of the German constitution lays out actions that Berlin can take.

The federal government can, with the consent of the upper house of parliament, compel the state to "fulfil its obligations".

If a state repeatedly refuses to comply with federal law, Berlin could in theory appoint a federal commissioner to enforce compliance, taking over some state functions and effectively sidelining ministers.

However security expert Luca Manns from the University of Cologne believes it is more likely a serious dispute between Berlin and a state would end up before the Constitutional Court.

This could happen, for instance, "if there is indeed a threat of the complete abolition of the local office of the domestic intelligence agency," he said.

M.Fujitav--JT