The Japan Times - There will be accountability for Ukraine crimes, eventually: expert

EUR -
AED 4.049686
AFN 71.676152
ALL 90.779281
AMD 398.026581
ANG 1.974288
AOA 1012.283804
ARS 1702.371395
AUD 1.631197
AWG 1.98487
AZN 1.873172
BAM 1.956413
BBD 2.227018
BDT 137.523112
BGN 1.955616
BHD 0.417135
BIF 3320.301095
BMD 1.102706
BND 1.42374
BOB 12.909047
BRL 6.258407
BSD 1.105657
BTN 104.146121
BWP 15.454074
BYN 3.312568
BYR 21613.03142
BZD 2.223817
CAD 1.574487
CDF 2552.763158
CHF 0.925065
CLF 0.027965
CLP 1100.587788
CNY 7.356977
CNH 7.351215
COP 3657.244701
CRC 495.459814
CUC 1.102706
CUP 26.536319
CVE 110.300078
CZK 24.421237
DJF 196.893509
DKK 7.475451
DOP 67.261696
DZD 151.013158
EGP 59.236037
ERN 16.540585
ETB 181.479337
FJD 2.514274
FKP 0.83426
GBP 0.834257
GEL 2.85594
GGP 0.83426
GHS 12.964123
GIP 0.83426
GMD 81.600184
GNF 9796.24868
GTQ 8.452688
GYD 231.323566
HKD 8.651448
HNL 29.732725
HRK 7.533647
HTG 144.998085
HUF 364.742515
IDR 20155.19937
ILS 3.550106
IMP 0.83426
INR 103.536898
IQD 1676.225476
IRR 2110289.219529
ISK 136.591817
JEP 0.83426
JMD 174.707145
JOD 0.78179
JPY 175.766844
KES 143.296215
KGS 96.415626
KHR 4542.506408
KMF 492.909526
KPW 992.435502
KRW 1470.13841
KWD 0.343427
KYD 0.921389
KZT 492.844501
LAK 24888.915223
LBP 99014.937895
LKR 367.755287
LRD 187.968073
LSL 18.692345
LTL 3.256004
LVL 0.667016
LYD 7.127299
MAD 10.957335
MDL 20.084387
MGA 5023.620401
MKD 61.559783
MMK 2315.206347
MNT 3974.182974
MOP 8.935901
MRU 44.717424
MUR 52.720585
MVR 16.986259
MWK 1917.318443
MXN 20.483662
MYR 4.512278
MZN 70.466624
NAD 18.69226
NGN 1483.668527
NIO 40.693495
NOK 10.565878
NPR 166.634749
NZD 1.997342
OMR 0.423995
PAB 1.105647
PEN 3.762179
PGK 5.04565
PHP 70.520251
PKR 305.752122
PLN 4.40398
PYG 6862.21345
QAR 4.030682
RON 5.349449
RSD 117.602473
RUB 90.967082
RWF 1635.835066
SAR 4.149638
SBD 8.929376
SCR 15.238908
SDG 663.277221
SEK 11.09113
SGD 1.420373
SHP 0.830319
SLE 25.41766
SLL 23123.190896
SOS 631.906691
SRD 41.340254
STD 22823.781319
STN 24.508016
SVC 9.675033
SYP 14337.379684
SZL 18.685926
THB 37.360218
TJS 10.199851
TMT 3.85947
TND 3.33296
TOP 2.655051
TRY 55.567815
TTD 7.505353
TWD 36.302724
TZS 2925.008455
UAH 50.271215
UGX 4566.452232
USD 1.102706
UYU 44.813845
UZS 13296.168186
VES 1006.637138
VND 28416.174142
VUV 133.118183
WST 3.099247
XAF 655.957
XAG 0.023221
XAU 0.000285375256
XCD 2.980117
XCG 1.992725
XDR 0.77967
XOF 655.957
XPF 119.331742
YER 260.845477
ZAR 18.659418
ZMK 9925.671052
ZMW 22.606292
ZWL 355.070781
SSP 6556.005635
MXV 2.298545
  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    19.81

    +0.5%

  • VOD

    -0.2500

    16.33

    -1.53%

  • CMSC

    -0.2800

    20.12

    -1.39%

  • RBGPF

    -2.0000

    65

    -3.08%

  • RIO

    -0.2500

    94.16

    -0.27%

  • BTI

    -1.2000

    54.85

    -2.19%

  • NGG

    -0.3000

    74.94

    -0.4%

  • GSK

    -0.3500

    49.35

    -0.71%

  • BCE

    -0.4200

    20.14

    -2.09%

  • CMSD

    -0.3400

    19.93

    -1.71%

  • BP

    -0.9100

    43.52

    -2.09%

  • RELX

    0.1700

    33.24

    +0.51%

  • BCC

    -0.6200

    75.97

    -0.82%

  • AZN

    -1.9400

    164.21

    -1.18%

  • JRI

    0.0000

    10.77

    0%

There will be accountability for Ukraine crimes, eventually: expert
There will be accountability for Ukraine crimes, eventually: expert

There will be accountability for Ukraine crimes, eventually: expert

Shocking images of bodies strewn in Ukrainian streets clearly indicate war crimes, but legally proving that and ensuring accountability is tricky, according to a top international justice expert.

Text size:

The calls for war crimes investigations and trials over Moscow's conflict in Ukraine have intensified after horrific photographs emerged of corpses in roads and in mass graves in Bucha, near Kyiv, after Russian troops retreated from the devastated town.

The Kremlin has denied responsibility and suggested the images are fake or that the deaths occurred after Russian forces pulled out of the area.

Philip Grant, who heads the TRIAL International NGO that works to ensure accountability for international crimes, said that, while powerful, such images alone cannot legally prove war crimes have occurred and who is responsible.

"Images in themselves rarely count as the defining evidence," he told AFP in an interview.

"They can reveal important elements, but they will not reveal the full story," he said.

Grant said it was important to be "cautious" when interpreting events, pointing to past examples of manipulation and misinterpretation.

There was, for instance, the dramatic misreporting that a massacre occurred during the 1989 Timisoara uprising in Romania, and Soviet efforts during the Nuremberg trials to pin its own 1940 Katyn massacre of Polish officers on Nazi Germany.

- 'Clear-cut' -

At the same time, Grant said, investigators should "exercise sound judgement" with what they can see.

In the case of the Bucha images, "it looks pretty clear-cut that war crimes have been committed," he said.

But the images alone do not make it possible to "attribute that responsibility to a specific person or to a specific group."

Even if it was determined that "Russians did it," he said, "that's not accountability. We need to know who ordered that."

"Is it (Russian President) Vladimir Putin? Is it the commander on the ground? Is it a rogue unit?"

"In terms of criminal liability," he said, "it's too early to say who should end up in court for those crimes."

That process can be long and complicated, he acknowledged.

As the International Criminal Court, the UN Human Rights Council and a growing number of countries begin sending war crimes investigators to Ukraine, they will have their work cut out for them, Grant said.

- Is it a crime? -

The first step is to "make sure you have a crime".

"It might look obvious, but it's not always," he said, pointing out that in war, unlike in civilian life, killing people can be lawful.

A soldier killed in battle is not considered a crime, but if that soldier is killed after being wounded or taken prisoner, it is.

And if you find a mass grave with soldiers killed in combat, "that is not a crime," Grant said.

But "if you find in the mass grave a family, civilians, that is probably a crime."

After determining a crime has been committed comes the even more complicated task of figuring out who is legally responsible.

With war crimes, you can have "many circles" of accountability, Grant said, from the perpetrator, to superiors who may have ordered the crime, or failed to exercise control over soldiers involved.

- Top-level liability -

"The levels go all the way up to the top," he said.

In cases where evidence points to top-level criminal liability, the main challenge is "getting access to the suspects," Grant said.

If the Ukraine investigations "point to criminal responsibility of Putin, you would need to put your hands on the person."

"That's not going to be something easy," he said, but "it is possible."

Importantly, there is no statute of limitation for war crimes.

Those involved could be held accountable even decades after the fact, as with former concentration camp guards and officials still being put on trial for crimes committed during World War II.

Grant said for Ukraine, even lower-level commanders and civilian authorities "could be liable for crimes committed for a long time to come."

"Putin is 69," he pointed out. "That leaves a little bit of room, but there are others."

"There are probably hundreds of people in the security apparatus who could at some point be held accountable, not even talking about the field soldiers."

S.Yamada--JT