The Japan Times - Toxic homes a lasting legacy of Los Angeles fires

EUR -
AED 4.199055
AFN 73.176343
ALL 93.736674
AMD 418.740472
ANG 2.047106
AOA 1049.030252
ARS 1698.78048
AUD 1.645562
AWG 2.058079
AZN 1.962695
BAM 1.955522
BBD 2.302573
BDT 140.901202
BGN 1.933315
BHD 0.431042
BIF 3402.231219
BMD 1.143377
BND 1.476597
BOB 7.916555
BRL 5.876164
BSD 1.143247
BTN 108.514523
BWP 15.440805
BYN 3.26545
BYR 22410.19818
BZD 2.299273
CAD 1.625505
CDF 2578.315681
CHF 0.921848
CLF 0.02691
CLP 1059.09933
CNY 7.770849
CNH 7.771508
COP 3836.820303
CRC 520.82596
CUC 1.143377
CUP 30.299503
CVE 110.250773
CZK 24.229483
DJF 203.583729
DKK 7.474539
DOP 67.510993
DZD 152.110291
EGP 55.856619
ERN 17.150662
ETB 183.392433
FJD 2.559682
FKP 0.855338
GBP 0.854109
GEL 3.012816
GGP 0.855338
GHS 13.050316
GIP 0.855338
GMD 84.046882
GNF 10026.70615
GTQ 8.722836
GYD 239.139141
HKD 8.966738
HNL 30.602917
HRK 7.534284
HTG 149.560047
HUF 353.886185
IDR 20456.680624
ILS 3.458774
IMP 0.855338
INR 108.506007
IQD 1497.6002
IRR 1572944.369234
ISK 143.791093
JEP 0.855338
JMD 180.054404
JOD 0.810647
JPY 185.114523
KES 147.826876
KGS 99.988572
KHR 4592.347155
KMF 493.362371
KPW 1029.040113
KRW 1730.764682
KWD 0.354092
KYD 0.952669
KZT 536.448431
LAK 25760.563196
LBP 102375.989365
LKR 382.758935
LRD 207.841362
LSL 18.569223
LTL 3.376097
LVL 0.691618
LYD 7.332958
MAD 10.69018
MDL 20.11514
MGA 4847.353298
MKD 61.641602
MMK 2400.427177
MNT 4099.700177
MOP 9.234387
MRU 45.622514
MUR 53.830285
MVR 17.665285
MWK 1981.944249
MXN 19.916778
MYR 4.654571
MZN 73.061641
NAD 18.569223
NGN 1567.273882
NIO 42.074387
NOK 11.213172
NPR 173.621318
NZD 2.008754
OMR 0.439627
PAB 1.143247
PEN 3.886481
PGK 5.024286
PHP 70.242257
PKR 317.844395
PLN 4.292479
PYG 6960.010569
QAR 4.167808
RON 5.233701
RSD 117.34716
RUB 87.180244
RWF 1675.369157
SAR 4.294937
SBD 9.258415
SCR 15.390648
SDG 686.598532
SEK 11.043311
SGD 1.476426
SHP 0.853647
SLE 27.86985
SLL 23976.057799
SOS 653.307126
SRD 43.097351
STD 23665.604914
STN 24.496732
SVC 10.003709
SYP 126.379909
SZL 18.558443
THB 38.033879
TJS 10.569136
TMT 4.001821
TND 3.381419
TOP 2.752979
TRY 53.555491
TTD 7.758897
TWD 36.705501
TZS 3001.369264
UAH 50.876512
UGX 4184.405147
USD 1.143377
UYU 46.013459
UZS 13738.047008
VES 761.736568
VND 30061.68013
VUV 137.371201
WST 3.164616
XAF 655.863763
XAG 0.018593
XAU 0.000275
XCD 3.090035
XCG 2.060307
XDR 0.815445
XOF 655.863763
XPF 119.331742
YER 271.066227
ZAR 18.561363
ZMK 10291.771981
ZMW 21.06419
ZWL 368.167075
  • VOD

    0.1250

    13.205

    +0.95%

  • RYCEF

    -0.6300

    19.46

    -3.24%

  • RBGPF

    0.1700

    68.32

    +0.25%

  • CMSC

    -0.0200

    22.04

    -0.09%

  • BCE

    0.6400

    21.51

    +2.98%

  • RELX

    0.7100

    32.98

    +2.15%

  • GSK

    0.5950

    53.685

    +1.11%

  • CMSD

    -0.0800

    22.15

    -0.36%

  • AZN

    2.4900

    192.65

    +1.29%

  • BP

    0.9700

    38.36

    +2.53%

  • NGG

    1.4000

    83.99

    +1.67%

  • RIO

    -2.0600

    91.52

    -2.25%

  • BTI

    0.7000

    62.16

    +1.13%

  • BCC

    -1.0850

    74.195

    -1.46%

  • JRI

    0.0300

    13.14

    +0.23%

Toxic homes a lasting legacy of Los Angeles fires
Toxic homes a lasting legacy of Los Angeles fires / Photo: Robyn Beck - AFP

Toxic homes a lasting legacy of Los Angeles fires

The fires that tore through Los Angeles nine months ago didn't destroy Karen Girard's home. But the smokeleft her walls, floors and furniture infused with a toxic cocktail.

Text size:

Tests have found heavy metals like lead, arsenic, and zinc, as well as volatile organic compounds like cyanide and furfural that have left her home uninhabitable.

When the flames razed neighboring houses in January during a terrifying firestorm in Altadena, Girard was astonished to learn her property was spared.

"I thought I should go out and buy lottery tickets, because I never thought I would be this lucky again," she told AFP.

But even after only short visits Girard finds herself suffering from increasing asthma attacks.

Tests revealed problems she couldn't see -- things she says mean the house is no longer safe.

"I realized that even though the home was still standing, it might be lost to me," the 58-year-old designer said.

- Unseen disaster -

The wildfires that ravaged the Los Angeles area in January killed 31 people directly, and razed more than 16,000 buildings, tearing a swathe through the working- and middle-class neighborhood of Altadena and the upmarket enclave of Pacific Palisades.

Horrifying pictures of a burned out landscape were broadcast around the world, showing acres (hectares) of almost unimaginable devastation, in one of the most expensive natural disasters the world has ever seen.

But among the embers smoldered another, less-visible disaster: the pollution released when homes, cars, televisions, household goods and batteries burned.

Driven by gusts reaching 100 miles (160 kilometers) and hour, this poisonous soup seeped under neighbors' doors and through vents.

"The potential toxicity of the mixture that came off these fires is probably much greater than what we saw in other major fires we've experienced in the US, because those fires did not affect as many urban structures," explained Michael Jerrett, a professor of environmental science at the University of California Los Angeles.

His team tested the atmosphere in affected communities this spring and found abnormal levels of hexavalent chromium, a carcinogen.

Nanoparticles could have been transported up to six miles, potentially affecting tens of thousands of people, he says.

"They are so small that they're capable of penetrating the indoor environment with high efficiency."

"It's really important that people trying to move back into their homes have them properly remediated."

But getting insurance companies to pay up has proven complicated.

Girard says she is stuck in a battle between experts, with the damage restoration company she hired recommending replacing all her furniture, and even treating the frame of her house.

The firm hired by her insurance company, however, insists that a vacuum cleaner equipped with a filter to capture fine particles will be enough to make the place habitable.

- Insurers -

To Girard it seems like the company is prioritizing profit over her wellbeing.

"While it feels like business to them, it doesn't feel like business to me," she said.

"This is my home. This is a place that I've lived for a couple of decades, and it is a place I desperately want to come home to."

Girard's insurer, Farmers, told AFP: "We continue to work with our customer to resolve this claim and remain willing to review any additional information they may wish to provide."

The problem when dealing with insurance companies -- a frequent topic of complaint in high-cost California, even without a major disaster -- is that they appear to be a law unto themselves, says Jane Lawton, founder of the Eaton Fire Residents United association.

"There are no clear standards on (smoke claims), so insurance companies can deny what they want," she said.

Her organization has mapped more than 200 tests conducted on homes in Altadena. All show varying degrees of contamination.

"This is going to be like 9/11," said Lawton, referencing the 2001 attack in New York where people in a wide area around the World Trade Center suffered from chronic respiratory illnesses and elevated rates of some cancers after the twin towers collapsed, releasing clouds of dust and debris.

California's largest insurer, State Farm, which has so far paid out $4.5 billion in relation to the fires, said it "evaluates each claim, including smoke claims, on a case-by-case basis."

But for Priscilla Munoz, they are dragging their feet.

Munoz, who lives a mile from the disaster area, spent $10,000 on a study that found lead in her home and still doesn't know if the insurer will pay to clean it up.

"Lead... goes into things," she says, worrying about her two young children and their plush toys.

"I don't want them snuggling up to a toxic stuffy."

S.Yamamoto--JT