The Japan Times - EU crypto regulation hampered by national flaws

EUR -
AED 4.040612
AFN 70.414515
ALL 90.730849
AMD 394.440725
ANG 1.969865
AOA 1009.469101
ARS 1705.239006
AUD 1.633039
AWG 1.983174
AZN 1.867186
BAM 1.957491
BBD 2.219317
BDT 137.188506
BGN 1.951235
BHD 0.416061
BIF 3308.88835
BMD 1.100235
BND 1.42044
BOB 12.853044
BRL 6.358271
BSD 1.101882
BTN 103.42505
BWP 15.423744
BYN 3.311075
BYR 21564.613891
BZD 2.216114
CAD 1.572533
CDF 2550.345726
CHF 0.923015
CLF 0.027899
CLP 1098.013028
CNY 7.332574
CNH 7.334015
COP 3649.733885
CRC 491.026389
CUC 1.100235
CUP 26.444844
CVE 110.360331
CZK 24.408998
DJF 196.224853
DKK 7.475781
DOP 66.968153
DZD 150.773462
EGP 59.080988
ERN 16.503531
ETB 180.852824
FJD 2.527022
FKP 0.834383
GBP 0.834006
GEL 2.855121
GGP 0.834383
GHS 12.908092
GIP 0.834383
GMD 80.868493
GNF 9762.521768
GTQ 8.421274
GYD 230.548104
HKD 8.632573
HNL 29.632597
HRK 7.51677
HTG 144.406053
HUF 364.515725
IDR 20074.895156
ILS 3.573676
IMP 0.834383
INR 102.787787
IQD 1670.442958
IRR 2118232.609704
ISK 136.814114
JEP 0.834383
JMD 174.710918
JOD 0.780098
JPY 174.988065
KES 143.151734
KGS 96.214927
KHR 4518.149248
KMF 492.359462
KPW 990.212247
KRW 1470.701139
KWD 0.342669
KYD 0.918293
KZT 490.263498
LAK 24809.430821
LBP 98673.484302
LKR 366.706768
LRD 187.315848
LSL 18.671814
LTL 3.248709
LVL 0.665522
LYD 7.119344
MAD 10.983338
MDL 20.153501
MGA 5012.466531
MKD 61.535447
MMK 2310.299493
MNT 3966.888137
MOP 8.904425
MRU 44.743854
MUR 52.657598
MVR 16.954932
MWK 1910.650453
MXN 20.341818
MYR 4.502386
MZN 70.316725
NAD 18.671729
NGN 1480.873231
NIO 40.545392
NOK 10.612948
NPR 165.47968
NZD 1.999766
OMR 0.423048
PAB 1.101847
PEN 3.757746
PGK 5.030528
PHP 70.080645
PKR 304.677293
PLN 4.402537
PYG 6838.093318
QAR 4.027879
RON 5.347911
RSD 117.633858
RUB 90.819935
RWF 1627.806127
SAR 4.140232
SBD 8.910103
SCR 15.223672
SDG 661.790631
SEK 11.09901
SGD 1.417175
SHP 0.834618
SLE 25.360082
SLL 23071.390306
SOS 629.743984
SRD 41.207669
STD 22772.651467
STN 24.522074
SVC 9.641328
SYP 14305.261075
SZL 18.666634
THB 37.177041
TJS 10.153448
TMT 3.861826
TND 3.330977
TOP 2.649103
TRY 55.471295
TTD 7.483464
TWD 36.202699
TZS 2913.536674
UAH 50.088433
UGX 4572.929395
USD 1.100235
UYU 44.737222
UZS 13233.43127
VES 1006.279256
VND 28321.159498
VUV 132.958939
WST 3.083636
XAF 655.957
XAG 0.02319
XAU 0.000284313982
XCD 2.973442
XCG 1.985815
XDR 0.777924
XOF 655.957
XPF 119.331742
YER 260.207906
ZAR 18.614954
ZMK 9903.433424
ZMW 22.561489
ZWL 354.275351
SSP 6543.048497
MXV 2.282034
  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    19.81

    +0.5%

  • VOD

    -0.2500

    16.33

    -1.53%

  • CMSC

    -0.2800

    20.12

    -1.39%

  • RBGPF

    -2.0000

    65

    -3.08%

  • RIO

    -0.2500

    94.16

    -0.27%

  • BTI

    -1.2000

    54.85

    -2.19%

  • NGG

    -0.3000

    74.94

    -0.4%

  • GSK

    -0.3500

    49.35

    -0.71%

  • BCE

    -0.4200

    20.14

    -2.09%

  • CMSD

    -0.3400

    19.93

    -1.71%

  • BP

    -0.9100

    43.52

    -2.09%

  • RELX

    0.1700

    33.24

    +0.51%

  • BCC

    -0.6200

    75.97

    -0.82%

  • AZN

    -1.9400

    164.21

    -1.18%

  • JRI

    0.0000

    10.77

    0%

EU crypto regulation hampered by national flaws
EU crypto regulation hampered by national flaws / Photo: Giuseppe CACACE - AFP

EU crypto regulation hampered by national flaws

The first EU-wide cryptocurrency regulation was meant to impose some harmony, but disparities in implementation by member countries has allowed companies to exploit a flaw in the system.

Text size:

Launched in December, Markets in Crypto-Asset (MiCA) insists on service providers obtaining a licence to operate legally in the European Union.

It is issued once specific criteria on anti-money laundering, prevention of terror group financing, IT security and financial soundness have been implemented.

Such a framework aims to protect investors and provide credibility to a sector deemed to be poorly regulated.

Once obtained, a licence grants access to the entire EU market, which encourages some companies to seek authorisation in the most "accommodating" member state.

Crypto experts, speaking to AFP, do not question the integrity of regulatory authorities in, for example, Germany and the Netherlands -- two EU members which account for the majority of the roughly 30 MiCA licences issued so far.

Other bloc nations, including Malta, are in the crosshairs, however, according to these same experts, who preferred to remain anonymous.

They point to, for example, the Mediterranean island hastily issuing licences before the formal implementation of collective standards.

- Rapid approvals -

"From time to time we see arriving on our market, via the (MiCA) passport, products approved by some of our colleagues with, let's say, a rather quick signing off," lamented the president of the financial markets authority in France, Marie-Anne Barbat-Layani, as she addressed the country's Senate in March.

Barbat-Layani noted that EU markets regulator ESMA had launched a "peer review" of an unnamed regulator that is potentially too lax.

When contacted by AFP, the watchdog declined to comment. The Maltese regulator, MFSA, neither confirmed nor denied that it was involved.

An official working under her, Stephane Pontoizeau, added: "There is always the risk of someone trying to find the least demanding entry point into Europe."

Crypto platform OKX, which had planned to hire about 100 staff in France making the country its "anchor" in Europe, ultimately opted for Malta.

Peer Gemini followed the same strategy, having targeted Ireland before changing its mind, citing the "proactive engagement" of the Maltese authorities.

"Malta began welcoming applications several months earlier than other regulators, which meant that we could start the application process earlier, build the teams and infrastructure required to operate under MiCA," noted Gemini's head of Europe, Mark Jennings.

Other countries have been slow to grant approvals, with France having only just issued its first MiCA licence -- to French fintech firm Deblock -- amid accusations that its process is long and complex.

France, however, sees it as granting companies greater time to prepare their application, with the country implementing a transition period through to June 2026.

Pontoizeau insisted the French financial regulator is "determined not to add national requirements to European rules".

According to lawyer Anne Marechal, former legal director at the regulator, there have been "cut-price approvals".

She told AFP that "believing one can save a few weeks and a little money" puts companies' credibility at risk with investors.

- Economic sovereignty -

Obtaining the necessary certification can also require considerable outlay, whether for a MiCA or national licence.

Tangi Le Calvez, founder of the crypto investment firm GOin, has invested about one million euros on obtaining a French licence, which inspired MiCA.

He believes that many players will not be able to complete all the necessary steps.

Already in 2017, EU member Estonia introduced its own mandatory licences for the crypto sector, which resulted in 75 percent of industry participants ceasing operations there, according to the Cointelegraph publication.

While it remains to be seen if a similar outcome will occur in the wake of MiCA, Claire Balva, strategy director at Deblock, highlighted the risk of European crypto firms being replaced by rivals from places with more flexible rules, such as the United States and Dubai.

Given their financial resources, such non-European companies would have no difficulty complying with EU rules, she insisted.

Should "a significant portion of cryptocurrencies held by Europeans" be hosted "on American infrastructure", this also raises "questions of economic sovereignty", added Balva.

T.Shimizu--JT