The Japan Times - Seize or freeze? Friction in Europe over Russian assets for Ukraine

EUR -
AED 4.031682
AFN 70.803249
ALL 89.802128
AMD 395.791487
ANG 1.965511
AOA 1006.685892
ARS 1726.870351
AUD 1.647859
AWG 1.976046
AZN 1.858467
BAM 1.957982
BBD 2.209563
BDT 136.452074
BGN 1.946922
BHD 0.413961
BIF 3304.388048
BMD 1.097803
BND 1.415271
BOB 12.808275
BRL 6.52743
BSD 1.097023
BTN 101.610243
BWP 15.641789
BYN 3.293456
BYR 21516.948362
BZD 2.206359
CAD 1.572653
CDF 2502.992255
CHF 0.922643
CLF 0.028326
CLP 1114.753567
CNY 7.318672
CNH 7.326693
COP 3766.102689
CRC 491.047266
CUC 1.097803
CUP 26.329224
CVE 110.390543
CZK 24.456372
DJF 195.357724
DKK 7.474428
DOP 66.183459
DZD 150.504115
EGP 59.077532
ERN 16.467052
ETB 180.060475
FJD 2.515672
FKP 0.837136
GBP 0.837717
GEL 2.848766
GGP 0.837136
GHS 12.917396
GIP 0.837136
GMD 81.237618
GNF 9725.839323
GTQ 8.385307
GYD 229.523118
HKD 8.606203
HNL 29.487729
HRK 7.500155
HTG 143.859675
HUF 372.335413
IDR 20049.898671
ILS 3.657574
IMP 0.837136
INR 101.678724
IQD 1663.14598
IRR 2126790.622064
ISK 137.159344
JEP 0.837136
JMD 173.78368
JOD 0.778349
JPY 174.434939
KES 142.791531
KGS 96.003038
KHR 4475.968023
KMF 492.914079
KPW 988.023523
KRW 1469.607173
KWD 0.342284
KYD 0.914219
KZT 500.42772
LAK 24730.561893
LBP 98244.492223
LKR 364.836606
LRD 183.754792
LSL 19.176785
LTL 3.241529
LVL 0.66405
LYD 7.097911
MAD 10.970727
MDL 20.108869
MGA 4971.540718
MKD 61.522411
MMK 2305.175661
MNT 3959.954055
MOP 8.857031
MRU 44.716836
MUR 51.35511
MVR 16.917044
MWK 1902.320111
MXN 20.832347
MYR 4.515156
MZN 70.160892
NAD 19.176785
NGN 1489.620919
NIO 40.374997
NOK 10.703782
NPR 162.575448
NZD 1.99865
OMR 0.422093
PAB 1.097023
PEN 3.765797
PGK 4.938616
PHP 70.070632
PKR 303.25137
PLN 4.451862
PYG 6917.930501
QAR 4.010297
RON 5.348612
RSD 117.617537
RUB 89.829785
RWF 1620.706256
SAR 4.122619
SBD 8.925822
SCR 15.324676
SDG 660.327047
SEK 11.203798
SGD 1.415563
SHP 0.834959
SLE 25.025569
SLL 23020.394262
SOS 626.995923
SRD 41.017786
STD 22722.315742
STN 24.527224
SVC 9.598698
SYP 14273.641319
SZL 19.172979
THB 37.213311
TJS 10.087664
TMT 3.85329
TND 3.322903
TOP 2.643248
TRY 55.524483
TTD 7.446299
TWD 36.131996
TZS 2929.082599
UAH 49.269732
UGX 4635.165833
USD 1.097803
UYU 44.609717
UZS 13133.63727
VES 1007.363967
VND 28324.976692
VUV 133.003489
WST 3.099409
XAF 655.957
XAG 0.025995
XAU 0.000307581213
XCD 2.966868
XCG 1.977204
XDR 0.776204
XOF 655.957
XPF 119.331742
YER 259.684967
ZAR 19.134018
ZMK 9881.548488
ZMW 22.588174
ZWL 353.492275
SSP 6348.208095
MXV 2.33524
  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    19.81

    +0.5%

  • VOD

    -0.2500

    16.33

    -1.53%

  • CMSC

    -0.2800

    20.12

    -1.39%

  • RBGPF

    -2.0000

    65

    -3.08%

  • RIO

    -0.2500

    94.16

    -0.27%

  • BTI

    -1.2000

    54.85

    -2.19%

  • NGG

    -0.3000

    74.94

    -0.4%

  • GSK

    -0.3500

    49.35

    -0.71%

  • BCE

    -0.4200

    20.14

    -2.09%

  • CMSD

    -0.3400

    19.93

    -1.71%

  • BP

    -0.9100

    43.52

    -2.09%

  • RELX

    0.1700

    33.24

    +0.51%

  • BCC

    -0.6200

    75.97

    -0.82%

  • AZN

    -1.9400

    164.21

    -1.18%

  • JRI

    0.0000

    10.77

    0%

Seize or freeze? Friction in Europe over Russian assets for Ukraine
Seize or freeze? Friction in Europe over Russian assets for Ukraine / Photo: Ludovic MARIN - AFP

Seize or freeze? Friction in Europe over Russian assets for Ukraine

As Europe scrambles to boost military aid to Ukraine, calls are intensifying to fund it by seizing tens of billions of euros in frozen Russian assets, in an issue causing tension between European allies.

Text size:

France on Tuesday voiced opposition to seizing frozen Russian assets, arguing such a move would be against international agreements in a stance that puts Paris at odds with its ally Britain.

The Baltic countries and Poland are also seen as strongly supporting seizing the assets, while Germany shares France's reservations that such a move would hinder postwar negotiations and also harm its investment image.

Tapping into the Russian assets would help plug a massive gap in defence budgets as Europe rushes to assume a greater role in defending Ukraine against Russia's invasion as American support for Kyiv wavers under President Donald Trump.

"France's position is that these Russian assets belong notably to the Russian central bank," French Finance Minister Eric Lombard told France Info radio Tuesday, and seizing such funds "would be contrary to international agreements that France and Europe have signed up to".

Foreign Minister Jean-Noel Barrot told parliament on Monday evening that billions of euros in income earned from the frozen Russian assets were already reaching Ukraine.

"But the pure and simple confiscation of these assets would represent too great a financial risk for the eurozone, for the European Central Bank, which would weaken member states at a time when they must be as strong as possible to support Ukraine," he said.

- 'Respect international law' -

Since the Russian invasion in February 2022, the EU and G7 have frozen some 300 billion euros of assets of the Russian Central Bank, according to the EU, as well as private assets of individuals such as yachts and real estate.

According to the Institute of Legislative Ideas, a Ukrainian anti-corruption think tank, some $397 billion has been frozen, mostly located in the EU with the vast majority of Russian Central Bank assets managed by Euroclear, an international fund depository based in Belgium.

European Union countries are already using income earned from frozen Russian assets to help arm Ukraine and finance its post-war reconstruction, a windfall worth between 2.5 billion euros and 3 billion euros a year.

"This is perfectly legal from the point of view of international law," said Frederic Dopagne, professor of international public law at Louvain University.

Confiscating the assets "would probably be a violation of international law, but this violation could be justified by international law itself," Dopagne added.

During his meeting at the White House with Trump last week, French President Emmanuel Macron himself came out against seizing the assets.

"You can take the proceeds of the frozen assets but you cannot take the assets themselves as this is not respecting international law and we want to respect international law," Macron said.

- 'Time to act is now' -

But that position has been criticized within France, with two of Macron's former premiers, Gabriel Attal and Edouard Philippe, backing a seizure.

It was now necessary to "move to the next level" with regard to Russia, Philippe said Tuesday, adding that frozen Russian assets should "be made fully available" to the Ukrainian war effort.

The British Guardian newspaper said Tuesday that the issue was causing "some tension" between the UK and France, which are currently leading European efforts to respond rapidly to Trump's abrupt change of policy on Ukraine.

"Of course Europe has to act quickly and I believe we should move from freezing assets to seizing assets," UK Foreign Secretary David Lammy told the British parliament last week, adding "we must act with European allies".

In Moscow, pro-Kremlin analyst Sergei Markov warned such a move would be "economic suicide" for Europe.

Russia "would cry scandal" and could seize the assets of European companies still operating in Russia such as retailer Auchan or DIY supplier Leroy-Merlin, he told AFP.

The Financial Times reported Tuesday that France and Germany are discussing with the UK and other countries ways in which the funds could be used, notably by allowing seizures should Russia violate a future ceasefire.

"This idea is a step in the right direction but we must do more and the time to act for Ukraine is now," said Estonian Foreign Minister Margus Tsahkna on X.

"Ukraine needs these funds now to change the dynamics of this war."

K.Yoshida--JT