The Japan Times - Well-off Hong Kong daunted by record deficits

EUR -
AED 4.029975
AFN 70.772261
ALL 90.083719
AMD 395.565472
ANG 1.964388
AOA 1006.111217
ARS 1733.264503
AUD 1.655278
AWG 1.977661
AZN 1.869556
BAM 1.956864
BBD 2.208301
BDT 136.374137
BGN 1.94581
BHD 0.41391
BIF 3298.11244
BMD 1.097176
BND 1.414463
BOB 12.800959
BRL 6.526888
BSD 1.096396
BTN 101.552207
BWP 15.632855
BYN 3.291574
BYR 21504.658624
BZD 2.205099
CAD 1.572567
CDF 2501.562727
CHF 0.921184
CLF 0.028438
CLP 1119.241113
CNY 7.314492
CNH 7.324059
COP 3821.257148
CRC 490.766797
CUC 1.097176
CUP 26.314185
CVE 110.568002
CZK 24.464885
DJF 194.990632
DKK 7.474054
DOP 66.054284
DZD 150.445267
EGP 59.037863
ERN 16.457647
ETB 176.978813
FJD 2.532836
FKP 0.836658
GBP 0.837623
GEL 2.847217
GGP 0.836658
GHS 12.919297
GIP 0.836658
GMD 81.191448
GNF 9720.983829
GTQ 8.380518
GYD 229.392023
HKD 8.599176
HNL 29.690021
HRK 7.495871
HTG 143.777507
HUF 373.631928
IDR 20061.81672
ILS 3.665722
IMP 0.836658
INR 101.647859
IQD 1661.125161
IRR 2125575.86999
ISK 137.191368
JEP 0.836658
JMD 173.68442
JOD 0.777942
JPY 174.20694
KES 142.721136
KGS 95.948503
KHR 4470.994461
KMF 492.632615
KPW 987.459198
KRW 1473.662012
KWD 0.342078
KYD 0.913697
KZT 500.141893
LAK 24719.386036
LBP 98252.152412
LKR 364.628224
LRD 184.05177
LSL 19.195145
LTL 3.239677
LVL 0.663672
LYD 7.093289
MAD 10.938305
MDL 20.097384
MGA 5030.554451
MKD 61.541059
MMK 2303.859024
MNT 3957.692266
MOP 8.851972
MRU 44.633554
MUR 51.32633
MVR 16.907904
MWK 1905.79589
MXN 20.884678
MYR 4.512252
MZN 70.120961
NAD 19.195145
NGN 1486.729376
NIO 40.33262
NOK 10.717324
NPR 162.48259
NZD 2.002462
OMR 0.421858
PAB 1.096396
PEN 3.783107
PGK 4.960377
PHP 70.13595
PKR 303.314843
PLN 4.458196
PYG 6913.979218
QAR 3.997056
RON 5.350385
RSD 117.631765
RUB 90.05113
RWF 1620.529632
SAR 4.113132
SBD 8.920723
SCR 15.33223
SDG 659.955674
SEK 11.21124
SGD 1.415319
SHP 0.838467
SLE 25.019646
SLL 23007.245807
SOS 628.137542
SRD 40.994357
STD 22709.33754
STN 24.796188
SVC 9.593215
SYP 14265.488708
SZL 19.211965
THB 37.251377
TJS 10.081902
TMT 3.851089
TND 3.345017
TOP 2.641738
TRY 55.492666
TTD 7.442046
TWD 36.166269
TZS 2928.858105
UAH 49.241591
UGX 4632.518386
USD 1.097176
UYU 44.584237
UZS 13160.632009
VES 1006.788595
VND 28308.798443
VUV 132.927522
WST 3.097639
XAF 655.957
XAG 0.026734
XAU 0.000311111872
XCD 2.965175
XCG 1.976074
XDR 0.775761
XOF 655.957
XPF 119.331742
YER 259.53749
ZAR 19.239121
ZMK 9875.908688
ZMW 22.575273
ZWL 353.290373
SSP 6344.582217
MXV 2.341106
  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    19.81

    +0.5%

  • VOD

    -0.2500

    16.33

    -1.53%

  • CMSC

    -0.2800

    20.12

    -1.39%

  • RBGPF

    -2.0000

    65

    -3.08%

  • RIO

    -0.2500

    94.16

    -0.27%

  • BTI

    -1.2000

    54.85

    -2.19%

  • NGG

    -0.3000

    74.94

    -0.4%

  • GSK

    -0.3500

    49.35

    -0.71%

  • BCE

    -0.4200

    20.14

    -2.09%

  • CMSD

    -0.3400

    19.93

    -1.71%

  • BP

    -0.9100

    43.52

    -2.09%

  • RELX

    0.1700

    33.24

    +0.51%

  • BCC

    -0.6200

    75.97

    -0.82%

  • AZN

    -1.9400

    164.21

    -1.18%

  • JRI

    0.0000

    10.77

    0%

Well-off Hong Kong daunted by record deficits
Well-off Hong Kong daunted by record deficits / Photo: Peter PARKS - AFP

Well-off Hong Kong daunted by record deficits

Hong Kong is facing its toughest fiscal test in three decades following a painful run of mammoth deficits, with experts urging the government to make careful cuts as the economy wobbles.

Text size:

The Chinese finance hub last saw a string of deficits after the Asian financial crisis in the late 1990s -- but their scale was a fraction of the HK$252 billion ($32.4 billion) shortfall in the 2020-21 fiscal year.

Hong Kong has recorded annual deficits exceeding $20 billion in three of the past four years, according to official figures.

The city's finance chief Paul Chan said Sunday that the deficits were caused by "multiple internal and external challenges" and that a new budget unveiled on Wednesday will tightly control public spending.

While Chan earlier predicted a return to surplus in "three or so years", a former government minister told AFP that the situation is "not just due to economic cycles" spurred by the coronavirus pandemic.

"If you look at Hong Kong versus other economies in the region, for example Singapore, those other economies have done much better," said Anthony Cheung, who oversaw transport and housing policies.

Adding to the headache is the exodus of companies and high-paid workers as the city's international reputation took a hit after Beijing quelled pro-democracy protests and imposed a sweeping national security law in 2020.

Singapore and Hong Kong suffered towering deficits in 2020 because of the pandemic, but the former has been able to keep spending relative to income in check as firms shift there from the Chinese city, helping it outperform its fiscal targets.

The challenge for Hong Kong is not just to balance its books, but to find fiscal sustainability amid US-China tensions and a slowdown in the world's second-largest economy, Cheung said.

"In the past, we assumed that Hong Kong was geopolitically well-positioned... Now we have to be more careful about such presumptions."

- Plunging land sales -

Hong Kong is required by its mini-constitution to "strive to achieve a fiscal balance" -- a holdover from British colonial rule that kept the market mostly free from government intervention.

After returning to China in 1997, it kept taxes low and refilled its coffers with the help of land-related revenue, selling land to developers with deep pockets.

But last year Hong Kong collected just $2.5 billion that way, from a peak of $21.2 billion in 2018.

"(Land-related revenue) by itself has contributed to the majority of the income decline," said Yang Liu, a financial economist at the University of Hong Kong.

"We have a very inactive land market and declining housing prices. That's one reason that people (don't) trade, so there's no tax (income)," Liu told AFP.

Hong Kong still has healthy cash reserves and low government debt compared with most economies around the world.

But the prospect of three straight years in the red has fuelled public debate on how to spend less.

"All the new initiatives will be under much stronger scrutiny, so (the government) will be a lot more disciplined, a lot more careful," Liu said.

In his upcoming budget speech, the finance chief is set to put the latest deficit at "under HK$100 billion", adjusting for money raised from bond sales.

There are calls to roll back a transport subsidy for those aged 60 to 64, which can grow into a major burden on the government as Hong Kong's population ages.

Lawmaker Edmund Wong cautioned against pay cuts for civil servants, which he said may cause private-sector employers to follow suit, but urged the government to slim down.

"In the long term, we can greatly reduce the manpower which the government is employing now," he told AFP.

- 'Welcoming' image -

The deficits could prompt Hong Kong to rethink how it makes money, though past discussions on expanding the tax base -- such as a goods and services tax -- went nowhere.

The city's low ratio of debt to GDP -- which the government last year put at no more than 13 percent -- means it can afford to issue bonds to fund huge undertakings, experts say.

Officials have signalled they will push ahead with a massive infrastructure project in northern Hong Kong, while backing away from a separate plan to create artificial islands.

As tensions flare between the United States and China, Hong Kong is seeking untapped growth potential in the Middle East and Southeast Asia that can translate to government revenue down the line.

The city's economic fortunes are ultimately tied to how investors view the city as a regional and global hub, said Cheung, the former minister.

"We have to continue to showcase Hong Kong as a city that welcomes all kinds of views, all kinds of people, so long as they stay within the parameters of the national security legislation," Cheung said.

K.Okada--JT