The Japan Times - Trump's birthright citizenship move challenges US identity: analysts

EUR -
AED 4.029739
AFN 70.778474
ALL 89.669173
AMD 395.464045
ANG 1.96456
AOA 1007.296808
ARS 1720.666958
AUD 1.64558
AWG 1.977834
AZN 1.86972
BAM 1.955128
BBD 2.206341
BDT 136.253158
BGN 1.945981
BHD 0.413358
BIF 3299.465689
BMD 1.097273
BND 1.413214
BOB 12.789603
BRL 6.528229
BSD 1.095423
BTN 101.462119
BWP 15.618631
BYN 3.288669
BYR 21506.546342
BZD 2.203143
CAD 1.574203
CDF 2501.782318
CHF 0.922196
CLF 0.028442
CLP 1116.636116
CNY 7.327314
CNH 7.332859
COP 3761.106983
CRC 490.331431
CUC 1.097273
CUP 26.290962
CVE 110.227105
CZK 24.468858
DJF 195.072937
DKK 7.47781
DOP 66.08728
DZD 149.391641
EGP 58.61085
ERN 16.459092
ETB 179.797988
FJD 2.514456
FKP 0.837372
GBP 0.838894
GEL 2.857146
GGP 0.837372
GHS 12.898566
GIP 0.837372
GMD 81.198575
GNF 9711.661263
GTQ 8.373121
GYD 229.181211
HKD 8.601467
HNL 29.444877
HRK 7.496529
HTG 143.650615
HUF 373.391377
IDR 20072.355965
ILS 3.666044
IMP 0.837372
INR 101.695794
IQD 1660.729064
IRR 2125817.320551
ISK 137.28022
JEP 0.837372
JMD 173.530343
JOD 0.77801
JPY 173.978128
KES 142.461024
KGS 95.956926
KHR 4469.463459
KMF 492.675859
KPW 987.545879
KRW 1477.105136
KWD 0.342108
KYD 0.912886
KZT 499.698211
LAK 24694.510363
LBP 98101.274117
LKR 364.304757
LRD 183.48692
LSL 19.148917
LTL 3.239962
LVL 0.66373
LYD 7.087563
MAD 10.954734
MDL 20.079097
MGA 4964.293344
MKD 61.533846
MMK 2304.446613
MNT 3958.888254
MOP 8.844159
MRU 44.651649
MUR 51.330836
MVR 16.902103
MWK 1899.546962
MXN 21.022046
MYR 4.513125
MZN 70.119822
NAD 19.148917
NGN 1486.804984
NIO 40.31614
NOK 10.711083
NPR 162.33919
NZD 2.006534
OMR 0.418806
PAB 1.095423
PEN 3.760307
PGK 4.931305
PHP 70.245251
PKR 302.809298
PLN 4.459811
PYG 6907.625252
QAR 4.004323
RON 5.352281
RSD 117.589574
RUB 89.402865
RWF 1618.343635
SAR 4.116755
SBD 8.914258
SCR 15.355277
SDG 660.013606
SEK 11.223898
SGD 1.414828
SHP 0.838605
SLE 25.07309
SLL 23009.265425
SOS 626.084761
SRD 40.997955
STD 22711.331007
STN 24.49158
SVC 9.584705
SYP 14266.740959
SZL 19.144418
THB 37.356693
TJS 10.072637
TMT 3.840455
TND 3.318059
TOP 2.64197
TRY 55.454853
TTD 7.435444
TWD 36.176649
TZS 2922.095423
UAH 49.196787
UGX 4628.408816
USD 1.097273
UYU 44.544686
UZS 13114.491416
VES 1006.876973
VND 28311.283441
VUV 133.341659
WST 3.097951
XAF 655.957
XAG 0.026772
XAU 0.000311300718
XCD 2.965435
XCG 1.974321
XDR 0.775829
XOF 655.957
XPF 119.331742
YER 259.618676
ZAR 19.332389
ZMK 9876.775613
ZMW 22.555246
ZWL 353.321385
SSP 6338.3417
MXV 2.356505
  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    19.81

    +0.5%

  • VOD

    -0.2500

    16.33

    -1.53%

  • CMSC

    -0.2800

    20.12

    -1.39%

  • RBGPF

    -2.0000

    65

    -3.08%

  • RIO

    -0.2500

    94.16

    -0.27%

  • BTI

    -1.2000

    54.85

    -2.19%

  • NGG

    -0.3000

    74.94

    -0.4%

  • GSK

    -0.3500

    49.35

    -0.71%

  • BCE

    -0.4200

    20.14

    -2.09%

  • CMSD

    -0.3400

    19.93

    -1.71%

  • BP

    -0.9100

    43.52

    -2.09%

  • RELX

    0.1700

    33.24

    +0.51%

  • BCC

    -0.6200

    75.97

    -0.82%

  • AZN

    -1.9400

    164.21

    -1.18%

  • JRI

    0.0000

    10.77

    0%

Trump's birthright citizenship move challenges US identity: analysts
Trump's birthright citizenship move challenges US identity: analysts / Photo: Stefani Reynolds - AFP

Trump's birthright citizenship move challenges US identity: analysts

Donald Trump's plan to end birthright citizenship could fundamentally reshape America, analysts said Tuesday, overturning a principle that has underpinned the country for more than 150 years.

Text size:

Moments after being sworn into office, the Republican president came out swinging, with a raft of executive orders aimed at slashing migration and changing how the US determines who is allowed to live here.

Most eye-catchingly, Trump took aim at previsions guaranteed in the 14th Amendment of the US Constitution that grant citizenship to anyone born on US soil.

"All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside," reads the document, which was ratified in 1868 as the postbellum US sought to knit itself back together.

If implemented, the order Trump signed on Tuesday would prevent the federal government from issuing passports, citizenship certificates or other documents to children whose mothers are in the country illegally or temporarily, and whose fathers are not US citizens or permanent residents.

Gil Guerra, an immigration policy analyst at US political think tank the Niskanen Center, said the notion of birthright citizenship is a defining characteristic of the American experiment.

The fact that everyone born here has a real stake in the country galvanizes a sense of cohesion that is absent in other systems, he said.

"It has helped assimilation by giving people who are born here an immediate sense of belonging," he told AFP.

"I think what people oftentimes overlook is that it also places responsibilities on the children of immigrants to see themselves as Americans and to be patriotic."

That feeds into the fierce pride that many Americans feel in their flag, their national anthem and in institutions like the military.

Making that precarious could have implications for social stability, said Guerra.

The modern United States has not suffered from the pockets of separatism that beset other world powers, like Russia, where tranches of the population feel like they don't belong.

"The US has managed to completely avoid that, because our political identity has for centuries now been borne on the premise that, if you're born in the US, you are an American," said Guerra.

- Supreme court -

Aaron Reichlin-Melnick, a senior fellow at the American Immigration Council, said the 14th Amendment was "crystal clear," and muddying the waters would have implications for people well beyond the babies born to illegal immigrants.

"All you needed before was a birth certificate proving you were born here... now, you'd have to show extensive documentation of your ancestry and your parents' citizenship," he told AFP.

"That makes everybody's life harder."

Trump supporters who fret about changing demographics sometimes complain that new arrivals and their children take resources that would otherwise be available for the established population.

But, says Guerra, the expansive approach to citizenship the US has historically taken has benefits to that very population -- whose own birth rate is plunging -- in terms of having enough working-age people to fund social security programs and to do the labor that a dynamic economy requires.

The demographic edge the US enjoys is also crucial in times of war.

Not "having a young population that can potentially serve in the military, in the events of conflict... could potentially endanger the United States," he said.

Trump's executive order faced an immediate legal challenge, with 22 states -- including California and New York -- suing to prevent its implementation.

The issue will almost certainly end up in the US Supreme Court.

While some legal scholars think Trump's efforts will come unstuck, a 6-3 conservative majority -- three of whom were appointed by Trump -- may have different ideas.

"I don't think it's inconceivable (that it will be upheld), which is what I would have said in 2019," Amanda Frost, a law professor at the University of Virginia told The New York Times.

"The ground is shifting."

M.Yamazaki--JT