The Japan Times - Christie's first-ever AI sale angers some artists

EUR -
AED 4.026028
AFN 70.713296
ALL 89.975777
AMD 395.350202
ANG 1.962751
AOA 1006.369229
ARS 1731.859883
AUD 1.657735
AWG 1.976013
AZN 1.867998
BAM 1.954627
BBD 2.205787
BDT 136.218281
BGN 1.944189
BHD 0.413515
BIF 3298.591042
BMD 1.096262
BND 1.41284
BOB 12.785921
BRL 6.521779
BSD 1.095128
BTN 101.435222
BWP 15.614419
BYN 3.287798
BYR 21486.741816
BZD 2.202589
CAD 1.57346
CDF 2499.478526
CHF 0.920954
CLF 0.028416
CLP 1118.374383
CNY 7.320566
CNH 7.319404
COP 3848.77974
CRC 490.20145
CUC 1.096262
CUP 26.283872
CVE 110.668115
CZK 24.464235
DJF 195.023892
DKK 7.473949
DOP 65.502105
DZD 150.383205
EGP 58.994485
ERN 16.443935
ETB 176.306435
FJD 2.530726
FKP 0.835961
GBP 0.83823
GEL 2.854515
GGP 0.835961
GHS 12.963346
GIP 0.835961
GMD 81.123803
GNF 9709.086823
GTQ 8.370711
GYD 229.115236
HKD 8.592559
HNL 29.68721
HRK 7.489626
HTG 143.612535
HUF 373.716383
IDR 20050.857406
ILS 3.662668
IMP 0.835961
INR 101.611515
IQD 1660.28931
IRR 2123859.73964
ISK 137.197654
JEP 0.835961
JMD 173.486714
JOD 0.777293
JPY 173.808561
KES 142.602226
KGS 95.868563
KHR 4467.26941
KMF 492.222173
KPW 986.636487
KRW 1475.690115
KWD 0.341793
KYD 0.912652
KZT 499.570301
LAK 24709.753471
LBP 98170.29271
LKR 364.206524
LRD 183.43828
LSL 19.228859
LTL 3.236978
LVL 0.663119
LYD 7.087379
MAD 10.954406
MDL 20.073683
MGA 5031.844509
MKD 61.498009
MMK 2301.939542
MNT 3954.394878
MOP 8.841896
MRU 44.585404
MUR 51.283567
MVR 16.886539
MWK 1904.208058
MXN 21.027083
MYR 4.50897
MZN 70.055252
NAD 19.228855
NGN 1498.316963
NIO 40.320942
NOK 10.724718
NPR 162.296156
NZD 2.006023
OMR 0.421495
PAB 1.095108
PEN 3.789235
PGK 4.950763
PHP 70.16792
PKR 303.089172
PLN 4.462391
PYG 6905.888562
QAR 3.993726
RON 5.349436
RSD 117.635543
RUB 89.970813
RWF 1617.907258
SAR 4.095619
SBD 8.906049
SCR 15.317007
SDG 659.405826
SEK 11.226691
SGD 1.414621
SHP 0.837833
SLE 25.050001
SLL 22988.077104
SOS 625.91594
SRD 40.960202
STD 22690.417042
STN 24.775529
SVC 9.582251
SYP 14253.603282
SZL 19.228846
THB 37.262361
TJS 10.070059
TMT 3.836918
TND 3.34223
TOP 2.639537
TRY 55.442156
TTD 7.433541
TWD 36.184554
TZS 2924.970833
UAH 49.183521
UGX 4627.076428
USD 1.096262
UYU 44.532675
UZS 13188.036287
VES 1005.94978
VND 28285.212702
VUV 132.816773
WST 3.095058
XAF 655.957
XAG 0.026747
XAU 0.000311014054
XCD 2.962704
XCG 1.973816
XDR 0.775114
XOF 655.957
XPF 119.331742
YER 259.379603
ZAR 19.271322
ZMK 9867.680482
ZMW 22.549575
ZWL 352.996025
SSP 6339.296169
MXV 2.357069
  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    19.81

    +0.5%

  • VOD

    -0.2500

    16.33

    -1.53%

  • CMSC

    -0.2800

    20.12

    -1.39%

  • RBGPF

    -2.0000

    65

    -3.08%

  • RIO

    -0.2500

    94.16

    -0.27%

  • BTI

    -1.2000

    54.85

    -2.19%

  • NGG

    -0.3000

    74.94

    -0.4%

  • GSK

    -0.3500

    49.35

    -0.71%

  • BCE

    -0.4200

    20.14

    -2.09%

  • CMSD

    -0.3400

    19.93

    -1.71%

  • BP

    -0.9100

    43.52

    -2.09%

  • RELX

    0.1700

    33.24

    +0.51%

  • BCC

    -0.6200

    75.97

    -0.82%

  • AZN

    -1.9400

    164.21

    -1.18%

  • JRI

    0.0000

    10.77

    0%

Christie's first-ever AI sale angers some artists
Christie's first-ever AI sale angers some artists / Photo: ANGELA WEISS - AFP

Christie's first-ever AI sale angers some artists

Christie's has launched its first-ever sale dedicated to artworks created with artificial intelligence, riding the AI revolution wave -- a move by the famed auction house that has sparked anger among some artists.

Text size:

The sale, titled "Augmented Intelligence," features about 20 pieces and runs online until March 5.

Christie's, like its competitor Sotheby's, has previously offered AI-created items but had never devoted an entire sale to this medium.

"AI has become more prolific in everybody's daily lives," said Nicole Sales Giles, Christie's head of digital art sales.

"More people understand the process and the technology behind AI and so are more readily able to appreciate AI also in creative fields," she said.

The launch of ChatGPT in November 2022 transformed public perceptions of generative artificial intelligence and opened new possibilities for its widespread use.

The market is now crowded with AI models that allow users to generate drawings, animated images or photo-realistic images through simple natural language requests.

The use of algorithms in the art world, it turns out, is almost as old as modern computing itself. Christie's is offering a work by American artist Charles Csuri (1922-2022) dating from 1966.

As a pioneer of computer art, he distinguished himself by using software to distort one of his hand-drawn sketches.

"All artists in the fine art sense, and particularly the artists that were featured in this auction, use AI to supplement their existing practices," said Sales Giles.

The collection includes paintings, sculptures, photographs and giant screens displaying entirely digital works.

Among the sale's highlights is "Emerging Faces" (estimated to sell for up to $250,000) by American artist Pindar Van Arman, a series of nine paintings resulting from a "conversation" between two AI models.

The first model paints a face on canvas while the second stops it when it recognizes a human form.

- 'Controversy and criticism' -

The sale has not been welcomed by all, and an online petition calling for its cancellation has gathered more than 6,300 signatures.

Many of the submitted works "were created using AI models that are known to be trained on copyrighted work without a license," it says.

The petition says the sale contributes to the "mass theft of human artists' work."

Several artists filed lawsuits in 2023 against generative AI startups, including popular platforms Midjourney and Stability AI, accusing them of violating intellectual property laws.

Digital art heavyweight Refik Anadol, who is participating in the event with his animated creation "Machine Hallucinations," defended the sale on X, saying the "majority of the artists in the project (are) specifically pushing and using their own datasets + their own models."

Petition signatory and illustrator Reid Southern said that at a minimum, pieces should be excluded that don't use the artist's own software or data -- accounting for perhaps one-third of the sale, he said.

"If these were oil paintings," he said, and there "was a strong likelihood that many of them were either counterfeit or forgeries or stolen or unethical in some way, I don't believe it would be ethical for Christie to continue the auction."

Sales Giles responded: "I'm not a copyright lawyer, so I can't comment on the legality specifically. But the idea that artists have been looking at prior artists to influence their current work is not new.

"Every new artistic movement generates controversy and criticism," she added.

"Midjourney is trained on basically the entirety of the internet," said noted Turkish artist Sarp Kerem Yavuz, who used this software to create "Hayal," also being auctioned at Christie's.

"There's so much information (out there) that you cannot infringe on individual copyright," he said.

Southern, the illustrator, pushed back.

"That's essentially arguing that it's bad to steal from one or two people, but it's okay to steal from millions of people, right?" he said.

S.Ogawa--JT