The Japan Times - Heatwave makes conditions 'inhumane', say inmates at overcrowded Paris suburb prison

EUR -
AED 4.281785
AFN 73.452334
ALL 95.429651
AMD 429.262728
ANG 2.087503
AOA 1070.299611
ARS 1646.071042
AUD 1.619085
AWG 2.098626
AZN 1.986664
BAM 1.958695
BBD 2.348401
BDT 143.127251
BGN 1.946965
BHD 0.439866
BIF 3469.728069
BMD 1.165903
BND 1.490102
BOB 8.056908
BRL 5.872776
BSD 1.165988
BTN 110.713639
BWP 15.645124
BYN 3.194922
BYR 22851.703681
BZD 2.345166
CAD 1.609005
CDF 2648.932604
CHF 0.910709
CLF 0.026367
CLP 1037.712648
CNY 7.88891
CNH 7.886595
COP 4305.843925
CRC 527.063197
CUC 1.165903
CUP 30.896436
CVE 110.615118
CZK 24.279007
DJF 207.204784
DKK 7.47393
DOP 68.019254
DZD 154.808958
EGP 61.006856
ERN 17.488549
ETB 184.21313
FJD 2.590409
FKP 0.865202
GBP 0.866681
GEL 3.113417
GGP 0.865202
GHS 13.688159
GIP 0.865202
GMD 84.532475
GNF 10236.630941
GTQ 8.894108
GYD 243.930539
HKD 9.137126
HNL 30.978502
HRK 7.532439
HTG 152.69569
HUF 353.842897
IDR 20780.651445
ILS 3.267036
IMP 0.865202
INR 110.773055
IQD 1527.333256
IRR 1575193.585016
ISK 143.359913
JEP 0.865202
JMD 183.645923
JOD 0.826672
JPY 185.738927
KES 150.879988
KGS 101.958687
KHR 4675.272437
KMF 492.011579
KPW 1049.144158
KRW 1757.506323
KWD 0.360778
KYD 0.971736
KZT 568.169776
LAK 25594.495481
LBP 104406.636357
LKR 384.788732
LRD 213.506078
LSL 18.934713
LTL 3.44261
LVL 0.705244
LYD 7.403929
MAD 10.707364
MDL 20.177824
MGA 4885.135018
MKD 61.616675
MMK 2448.448944
MNT 4174.360155
MOP 9.409465
MRU 46.636533
MUR 55.229278
MVR 17.959269
MWK 2025.174346
MXN 20.234022
MYR 4.629223
MZN 74.507092
NAD 18.934708
NGN 1599.273829
NIO 42.637521
NOK 10.78869
NPR 177.141822
NZD 1.949182
OMR 0.449196
PAB 1.166023
PEN 3.963493
PGK 5.077554
PHP 71.672781
PKR 324.762787
PLN 4.231005
PYG 7015.36898
QAR 4.245098
RON 5.251349
RSD 117.38435
RUB 82.95033
RWF 1705.133502
SAR 4.398141
SBD 9.365071
SCR 15.814297
SDG 700.129187
SEK 10.790487
SGD 1.48863
SHP 0.870465
SLE 28.685495
SLL 24448.410635
SOS 666.317977
SRD 43.337211
STD 24131.843306
STN 24.95033
SVC 10.202905
SYP 128.869732
SZL 18.934699
THB 37.979343
TJS 10.762507
TMT 4.080661
TND 3.374168
TOP 2.807215
TRY 53.459583
TTD 7.920707
TWD 36.640613
TZS 3065.839407
UAH 51.641442
UGX 4395.364568
USD 1.165903
UYU 46.767721
UZS 14017.076029
VES 639.713683
VND 30677.82924
VUV 137.641842
WST 3.165657
XAF 656.927964
XAG 0.015488
XAU 0.000257
XCD 3.150912
XCG 2.101443
XDR 0.815557
XOF 655.824767
XPF 119.331742
YER 278.188699
ZAR 19.000364
ZMK 10494.532504
ZMW 21.432678
ZWL 375.42037
  • CMSC

    -0.1000

    22.74

    -0.44%

  • BCC

    -0.6300

    69.72

    -0.9%

  • GSK

    -0.7000

    50.54

    -1.39%

  • CMSD

    0.0400

    22.93

    +0.17%

  • JRI

    0.0600

    12.92

    +0.46%

  • RBGPF

    -0.0100

    63.54

    -0.02%

  • RIO

    -0.0800

    106.39

    -0.08%

  • BCE

    0.2000

    25.11

    +0.8%

  • BTI

    -1.1300

    61.79

    -1.83%

  • RYCEF

    0.7000

    18

    +3.89%

  • AZN

    0.3400

    185.67

    +0.18%

  • VOD

    0.0300

    14.96

    +0.2%

  • NGG

    -1.1562

    81.53

    -1.42%

  • BP

    0.2800

    41.87

    +0.67%

  • RELX

    -0.3100

    32.79

    -0.95%

Heatwave makes conditions 'inhumane', say inmates at overcrowded Paris suburb prison
Heatwave makes conditions 'inhumane', say inmates at overcrowded Paris suburb prison / Photo: JULIEN DE ROSA - AFP/File

Heatwave makes conditions 'inhumane', say inmates at overcrowded Paris suburb prison

A damp towel hangs from a barred window, a fan churns the muggy air: Inmates at the overcrowded Villepinte prison outside Paris say enduring a heatwave that has stifled France in recent days in cramped cells is "inhumane".

Text size:

French MP Clementine Autain witnessed the conditions during an unannounced visit on Friday afternoon to the penitentiary in the Seine-Saint-Denis Paris suburb, accompanied by AFP.

Inmates told the left-wing parliamentarian of the impacts of waiting out the heatwave that saw record-breaking May temperatures in France in recent days in cells measuring nine square metres (100 square feet).

"At night, it's hot, and mosquitoes get in even though I try to make a sort of mosquito net with my laundry bag," said one teenaged detainee, adding that "tensions rise more quickly in the heat".

As Autain visited, another young prisoner was taken back to his cell in a wheelchair after collapsing in the yard.

Minors have individual cells, but in the rest of the building it is increasingly common for three detainees to share.

The Villepinte prison has an official capacity of 703, but at the time of Autain's visit it held 1,332 inmates.

The overcrowding forces nearly 200 prisoners to sleep on mattresses on the floor or on makeshift bed frames.

On Thursday, the UN Subcommittee on Prevention of Torture (SPT) raised the alarm over "severe prison overcrowding" in France, warning conditions in some facilities "may violate the fundamental rights" of detainees and "may constitute inhuman or degrading treatment under international law".

As of May 1, a new record was set, with 88,654 inmates in France, according to the monthly justice ministry figures.

In one cell, a 20-year-old inmate indicated his makeshift bed, overturned shelf and bottles of water. "I've been set up like this for a year," he said.

- 'Crammed into a cell' -

The men passed the hours watching a 24-hour news channel reporting extensively on the impact of the heatwave that has smashed temperature records across Europe, beyond the peeling prison cell walls.

"We're only entitled to three showers a week: Monday, Wednesday, Friday," one inmate told the MP, who appeared taken aback.

Limited access to the shower block, where mould riddles the ceilings and walls, is a result of overcrowding.

The prisoner does not deny the usefulness of detention, but said "at least they should put us in better conditions".

Nicolas "Sarkozy in prison, I don't get the feeling he had the same conditions as you", said Autain, referring to the former French president who spent several weeks in prison late last year.

For the inmate in his thirties, awaiting a trial date while enduring the heat amounted to what he called "double punishment".

"If there are three of us crammed into a cell like this, it's because the justice system is too slow," he said, as a fellow prisoner called for "alternatives like ankle tags".

Prison officers, clad in bulletproof vests, also struggle with the oppressive heat but say they remain attentive.

"We keep an eye on vulnerable people, especially older inmates. We give them bottles of water," said one female officer, who recounted stopping a young man who was going outside without water and a hat.

Located up against a highway, the prison complex added a "Respect" unit in 2017, inspired by a Spanish experiment, in which prisoners can move around freely.

An undeniable advantage during heat waves is their free access to showers.

"Since it's an old prison, the water is cold in winter and scalding hot in summer," a prisoner qualifies.

Even in these cells where the keys are left in the open door, "there's a lack of air: two people can manage, but three is inhumane", added the man in his fifties.

H.Takahashi--JT